Please sign in to post.

Money

Hey guys, just curious as to what most people do that travel to Italy. Do you usually take a bunch of cash out at the ATM when you get to the airport or do you continue to use your debit card for every transaction? I know I have a 3% charge for every transaction and a $7.50 charge total for every time I use the ATM. I just wanted to make sure there wasn't anything I was missing as to the best and most convenient route to go? I didn't know if most places in Italy only took cash or card etc.

Thanks a lot for the help!

Stephen

Posted by
5687 posts

I use an ATM card from my credit union, and I get charged 0% every transaction plus $0.00 charge total for every time I use the ATM. Most ATM machines in Europe don't charge a fee (they exist but I've never been charged a fee). Time to move to a new financial institution that doesn't charge you such rip-off fees. I recommend a good credit union.

Posted by
7178 posts

Depending on where you are going, there may be places that take cash only, also some smaller hotels will give discounts for cash that might be worth it. I usually try to estimate my costs for 2-3 days at a time so I'm not withdrawing amounts too often or carrying large amounts of cash on me for longer than that. I usually only use my credit or debit cards for large purchases (rental cars, train tickets, hotels, higher priced restaurants, etc.) and use cash for most smaller purchases (markets, small souvenirs, entrance fees, small cafes/coffee shops/snack stands, etc). It seems like almost everybody has their own system for cash vs cards that works for them - I always tend to lean toward more cash and less cards, but that's just me.

I agree with the above poster. You don't necessarily need to switch financial institutions (I didn't) but you might want to open a credit union account just for travel expenses, or set up an online bank account for ATM withdrawals only (not credit cards). I actually set up two online bank accounts (Ally Bank and Capital One) so my travel funds were spread about and I wouldn't lose everything if a card got stolen or hacked. It was easy to move money from my normal bank account into one or both of these accounts if/when I needed more available funds. Worked well for me.

Posted by
16730 posts

Do you usually take a bunch of cash out at the ATM when you get to the
airport...

Yes or at the nearest bank once we get into the city. As we've traveled Europe multiple times, we come home with a stash to get us started on the next trip so we can usually wait to hit a bank ATM. You may want to get 100 euro or so before you leave home to pay for your transport to the hotel or whatever until you can get to a bank ATM, and fees will depend on your individual bank. We like to keep the amount of cash transactions to a minimum so we withdraw more versus less at one time but we all have the method that works for us!

We never, ever use a credit card for withdrawing cash: our bank-issued debit/credit ATM cards only.

...or do you continue to use your debit card for every transaction?

No. Enough places in Italy still work on a cash-only basis that we need a healthy amount of cash on hand at all times. The restaurant that has the CC. stickers in the window? Their CC readers may (mysteriously) be down when it comes to paying the bill. We've also stayed in a family-run hotel which operated on a cash-only basis.

Posted by
5676 posts

Do you usually take a bunch of cash out at the ATM when you get to the
airport or do you continue to use your debit card for every
transaction?

Neither. We get a few hundred euro from our bank at home. Then we use our ATM/ debit card to withdraw more cash from bank ATMs as needed. We will tend to take out the max allowable to reduce the number of transaction charges. We NEVER use our debit card for anything else. Cash is used for smaller purchases. Larger purchases, hotels, nicer meals, etc, are paid with a credit card. It's just safer than using a debit card.

Posted by
36 posts

Thank you for all the great advice! We have already paid for airfare, all hotel stays, train rides, and some tours as we have been planning for awhile so the only spending we will be doing will be for food/drinks and maybe some tickets to go see something and a few little gifts etc. so I may just do the cash route to make it easy. I have found a bank here at home that will give us Euros before we go which will make it easier for at least the first few days we are there, then we can get more out. As usual, everyone has been real helpful on this forum so thanks again!

Posted by
11613 posts

Stephen, remember to keep some Euro for your next trip!

Posted by
605 posts

I usually get 100 euro from my home bank so that I am ready when landing at my destination. If I know I'll be having a large expense, such as taking a taxi, I might take a little more than that. While traveling, I only use my ATM card to withdraw money from the bank; fortunately, my bank does not charge a fee. I pay everything in cash, including hotel bills. My credit card stays in my money belt for emergencies only. Once my home bank was closed for maintenance and I couldn't withdraw cash from an ATM. That was the only time I used a credit card to pay my hotel bill. I will add, however, that if I had a credit card that does not charge a foreign transaction fee (my current card charges 2%), then I might consider using my card for hotel bills. It helps to know what your upcoming expenses will be from day to day so that you can plan your ATM withdrawals accordingly.

Posted by
1042 posts

We got the Capital One CC with no transaction fees specifically for our trip to Italy. Now we use that one all the time. So this is what we did:

  1. Each of us took our Capital One card, as they each have their own account number on them. That way is one of us lost one, we still had the other.
  2. We still took our chase card for emergencies, but always left it in the safe.
  3. We got 400 euro before we left, as we didn't want to fool around with it once we landed.
  4. We got euros just a couple times more through the trip as we always tried to use our CC.
Posted by
7054 posts

I use a credit union debit card to get cash out (1% for each transaction, no other fees). I withdraw a little cash at the airport and then more in the city, only as I need it. I use my credit card whenever I can (Capital One - no foreign exchange fees) and don't carry much cash at any time. There are ATMs everywhere (except maybe in the smallest of towns). My cash withdrawals in recent travels have been quite minimal.

Posted by
2215 posts

I'll join the group that gets about 2 or 3 day's cash before leaving. Also, my bank's web site provides a link that shows all ATM's that accept their card. We got a traveler's credit card to use on overseas trips that's not tied to any of our other accounts.

I like to get the lay of the land first, instead of looking like a confused tourist in front of the ATM. We actually used little cash, almost everywhere accepted our credit card. I never had more cash with me than what I'd be willing to lose (if she could, my wife would chime in and point out that's about 5 euros).

Posted by
488 posts

I just hit up an ATM at the airport upon arrival. I'm sure my bank could supply me with some Euro, but I hesitate to even ask what kind of fee they'd charge. I have a few banks, and they have different fees. So, I use the lowest fee bank card, with a backup on the second lowest, incase card 1 has problems.

Posted by
5837 posts

I have not had difficulty locating ATM cash machines at airports or obtaining local cash from airport ATMs. However, I found that the VCE airport ATM rejected my request for a 300 EUR withdraw but worked when I reduced my ask for 200 EUR.

Your account's $7.50 charge per transaction (plus 3%) converts to a big expense on a percentage basis for smaller amounts like 200 EUR. I would find a lower FX cost transaction cost account.

Posted by
11613 posts

Banks normally don't charge a fee for purchasing euro, but if they don't stock it, you will pay a FedEx charge for delivery.

Posted by
3522 posts

While banks don't charge "fees", they don't give you a good exchange rate when you buy foreign currency at a local US branch.

For example: Today the interbank rate on EUR is about 1.14. My local Chase quoted a rate of 1.25 to me this morning if I wanted to buy from them. But no FedEx charge since it gets delivered along with their normal armored car shipments.

Eleven cents per Euro sounds like a "fee" to me. :-)

Posted by
488 posts

For example: Today the interbank rate on EUR is about 1.14. My local Chase quoted a rate of 1.25 to me this morning if I wanted to buy from them.

While not technically a "fee," that's an $11/100 Euro vigorish, which is pretty horrible considering my worst bank will charge me 3% on the foreign ATM transaction... One way or the other, you pay something for the service, though my one bank (with the fewest network ties listed on the card), charges 0% for the foreign transaction. Winner if it works.