I have started planning a second trip to Italy — in late April/May 2027 — for my wife and me. Our first — 2023 — was an 8-member, 10-day group tour that took in Venice, Valdobbiadene, Schio, Valdagno, Soave and Lake Garda. We also did 3 days in Florence on our own. This time we are doing a 7-day yoga retreat near Siena and then staying an additional 3 weeks. We are an active couple in our early 70s who seek out local cuisine, history, walks exploring neighborhoods, wineries and coastlines. We usually stay in apartments for a minimum of 3 nights, which allows me the opportunity to explore local markets and create a meal for ourselves. I can’t pass up going into a cathedral and a highlight is when there is a concert with a choir and organ performance. I was thinking after Siena, we would head to Rome (Roman history, Vatican and other top sites), then Sorento (as a base for exploring Pompeii and Herculaneum) then onto Calabria (to explore southern coastal Italy). We are comfortable with public transportation and renting a car (except in larger cities). During the past 3 years I have put together itineraries — often with the help of people in the Rick Steves forum — for the Burgundy, Alsace, Brittany and Normandy regions of France and 3 weeks in the Algarve, Alentejo and Porto regions of Portugal.
What’s you most likely place to fly home? Unless it’s Calabria, I would do Rome last. So, train to Naples after Siena, rent a car for Calabria (compare doing so at NAP or Salerno vs your entry city in Calabria via train), then finish off with Rome—easy peasy!
I would do a week in each place, but you may find breaking it up works depending on your final list.
I don't know if you'll have time while in Siena (not sure if you must stay at the yoga retreat and unable to explore on your own), but the Siena area is a great base for exploring the Tuscan hill towns. That could be done by bus (Siena is the transportation hub of the Siena province), but, since smaller towns are not necessarily served frequently by bus, a rental car is probably the more efficient way to visit those rural areas. I recommend at least 4 nights to see the many towns in the area. If you can visit during your yoga retreat, do so, if not, add 3 or 4 nights to your stay there.
Rome needs 4 nights at the very least. If you also want to add a day trip to Orvieto and one to Tivoli, add a couple of nights.
Sorrento is a great base for the Naples area (Sorrento, Naples, Pompeii, Capri and the other islands, Amalfi Coast, Herculaneum, even Paestum). Given the vast amount of things to see, you can easily spend at least a week in the area.
Another increasingly popular area is Puglia (the heel of the boot). A car is the more efficient way to visit it, but it is entirely possible to accomplish the same using trains and buses. Vieste (Gargano peninsula, the spur of the boot), Matera (Basilicata), Polignano, Monopoli, Alberobello, Locorotondo, Ostuni, Lecce, Otranto, Gallipoli, are just some of the most popular places to visit. Given the vastity of places to see, Puglia needs a minimum of 8-10 days.
If you do decide on the beautiful Puglia region. The San Nicola Festivsl in Bari is May 7-9. I’ve attended Day 2 & 3 in 2024 & 2025 and recommend it.
I haven’t attended this one, but you might be very interested:
Maggio Musicale Fiorentino (Florence): A month-long classical music, opera, and ballet festival highlighting world-class performances.
We have taken 3 trips to Calabria and enjoyed it very much. Renting a car from Naples or Salerno would allow you to explore more of the coast. We have found street parking even in Tropea. Along the coast look at the Hotel Ducal in Cirella. It it a charming (not fancy) historic hotel with wonderful sea views. An excellent breakfast is served on a large balcony. Last year we stayed at an Airbnb in Tropea with free parking and great location. Let me know if you want the details.
We have been to Italy many times and it is our favorite foreign country.
In Tuscany there are many small towns or cities.
https://www.earthtrekkers.com/best-things-to-do-in-tuscany/
https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attractions-g187893-Activities-Tuscany.html
Pisa, Lucca, Voltera, San Gimignano, Pienza, and Cortona.
Also, nearby Umbria, for Assisi, Spoleto, Spello, Perugia, Gubbio and Orvieto.
MORE time in Rome, I have been there twice for a total of 12 days and not seen it all.
If you visit Portugal, in my opinion, Porto and the Douro River Valley beats the heck out of the Algarve. We can go on the beach in the USA.
Nothing wrong with southern Italy, but Rome, Florence, Tuscany and Umbria are the best.