Our family is planning a trip to Italy in January 2027. I read in Rick Steves Italy book that it was recommended to skip Cinque Terre. We would really like to go there. Is the issue the weather or something else? Thank you
It pretty well shuts down. Many restaurants close starting Nov 1 and lodging options diminish. Sure, there are some services and restaurants open but it off-season, subject to wet weather, even storms. Look at weather history for a few years at https://www.wunderground.com/weather/it/vernazza.
Sounds like Monterosso has the most options for lodging and restaurants during the off season. The trains do run between villages but less frequently and yes, the weather may be wet or downright stormy which eliminates hiking and makes walking even the cobblestone streets difficult. I guess it all depends on what you want to do and see, knowing that there will be limits to what is available.
January is not the best time to visit that area. As others have mentioned, many of the restaurants, hotels and other "tourist businesses" will be closed for the winter. They typically start to reopen for the season in about mid-to-late March. The weather could be wet and miserable, so it probably wouldn't be the most pleasant travel experience. Hiking the Sentiero Azzurro trails is a popular activity but those are usually closed in the winter.
You could also have a look at Levanto, the town just north of Monterosso (about five minutes on the train). It's a bit larger and there may be a few restaurants and other businesses open.
We visited Cinque Terre in early November and can confirm what others have said above- things start shutting down then (the hotel we were staying at was closing for the season the day after we left). We also had terrible weather- we had intended to do some walking along the coast path but it rained the entire time. We still managed to enjoy ourselves and take the train between the villages but I don't think I would choose to visit in winter.
In January a large city like Rome will be active. A friend said Venice in winter can be pleasant.
I suspect there is a recurring problem in this kind of posts. Italy has the image of a Mediterranean country, hot and sunny.
What Italy isn't, Italy is not a tropical country where the weather is stable during the year; Italy has seasons, and if the summer is hot and sunny, the winter is wet and bleak.
Neaples (that's southern Italy) is at the same latitude of New York, and even if Mediterranean is an hotter sea than the Atlantic, winter is still winter.
Italy has a climate similar to Northern California. In January it is not as freezing cold as North Dakota or Minnesota, but it is not beach weather like in Hawaii either. Leave the Cinque Terre for another trip if you are traveling in January.
For a January trip I would stick to bigger cities (Florence, Rome, Venice, etc.) where there lots of things to see indoor even if the weather is nasty outside, and if the weather happen to be good, you can take a day trip to a small town nearby.