Please sign in to post.

Italy itinerary bottom of country to top - advice, please

Hello, All! I hope that everyone is doing well today.

In May of this year my husband and I travelled within Portugal, essentially, from top to bottom and from side to side. We traveled for about a month which was our longest trip to date. We rented a car and meandered through the country and had a wonderful, unrushed visit. (Trip report posted.) We had done something similar in Slovenia/Croatia/Montenegro two years prior and that trip was also great, but needed a bit more time. With that in mind, I've been giving serious consideration to doing something similar in Italy. Please know that my husband and I have been to Rome, Florence, Venice, Tuscany, Umbria, and Cinque Terre in previous visits. Absolutely loved them all!!! And those agriturismo dinners around the table with others!! So memorable. But I digress....

The plan is to return to Italy next May/June and/or Sept/Oct. We recently got out our (workplace) white board and started listing the places that we really wanted to visit next. After a lot of research and discussion, we came up with a rough draft itinerary and lodging. Undecided is whether we will make one or two trips out of this list since it grew in the process. We want it to make sense and be enjoyable. Overall, we like a leisurely pace with time to get a feel for a place and its surrounding area. BTW, we would want a car in Basilicata/Puglia region, in Tuscany, and in the Dolomites but not on the Amalfi coast, Bologna, Verona, lakes...

I have some logistical questions but, for now, I'm interested in your thoughts on the itinerary below and, if familiar, the lodging choices.

Night 1 - Fly ATL to FCO

Nights 2, 3, 4 - Sorrento (Villa Monica B&B); Day trips: Pompeii and Capri

Nights 5, 6, 7, 8 - Positano (Venus Inn B&B); Day trips: Amalfi, Ravello, Minori... hike Path of the Gods

Nights 9, 10 - Castelmezzano (La Gradinata B&B); Day trips; See Paestum on the way to Castelmezzano, Pietrapertosa (entire area looks scenic)

Nights 11, 12 - Matera (B&B Al Convento)

Nights 13, 14, 15 - Locorotondo area (Agriturismo Masseria Aprile); Day trips: Alberobello, Cisternino, Ostuni, Martina Franca, Polignano al Mare, Monopoli

Nights 16, 17, 18 - Lecce (Roof Barocco Suite B&B); Day trips: Gallipoli, Santa Maria di Leuca, Torre Sant' Andrea, Grotta della Poesia

Nights 19, 20, 21, 22 - Pienza area (Agriturismo Podere Spedalone); Day trips to nearby towns but mostly here to catch our breath and enjoy the agriturismo in a beautiful setting

Nights 23, 24, 25 - Bologna (Antica Residenza d'Azeglio); Day trips: Ravenna, Parma, Modena

Nights 26, 27, 28 - Verona (Residenza Palazzo Negri); Day trips: Lake Garda (possibilities are Sirmione, Garda, Malcesine), Vicenza, Padua

Nights 29, 30 - Western Dolomites (either The Laurin, Garni Crepaz, or Hotel Uhrerhof-Deur in the Val Gardena area); Day trips and/or hikes: Puez-Odle Altopiano, Seceda...

Nights 31, 32 - Eastern Dolomites (Villa Alpina in Cortina d'Ampezzo); Day trips and/or hikes: Rifugios Averau and Nuvolau, Cinque Torri, Lago di Braies...

Nights 33, 34 - Varenna (Albergo Milano); Day trip to Bellagio...time on the lake

Night 35 - stay near MXP airport

I would sincerely appreciate your feedback. Thanks!!

Posted by
28247 posts

Lovely places, but it seems to me there are quite a few stops with too many day trips listed for the time you'll have available. I say that as someone who is always totally dependent on public transportation, however.

Although a day trip from Bologna to Ravenna will allow you to see the seven major mosaic sites, it won't be sufficient for some of the things I really enjoyed: the historic center, some more-minor mosaic sites, the mosaic museum and the art museum. The latter usually has an exhibition of contemporary mosaics, though it wasn't open in September 2022. I'd recommend 3 nights in Ravenna.

Padua's worthy of being more than a day trip from Verona.

I think you should split the itinerary across two trips. That might allow you to include Sicily.

Posted by
7168 posts

I agree with Acraven, it seems that some of the places you're staying you don't have enough time to actually see that place because you have so many day trips planned. Granted I am not familiar with all those places so maybe some of those 'day trip' places will be multiple places seen on one day trip and maybe your base locations are just being used to see other places in the area and you're not that interested in them of themselves.. I have done day trips from a base location that included two other locations for 1/2 day each and sometimes that works and it's enough to get a taste. However, that doesn't jibe with your statement "Overall, we like a leisurely pace with time to get a feel for a place and its surrounding area". Somehow I don't see that happening with this itinerary. We all travel differently, but even if you like a fast paced trip I think this would best be done as two trips.

Posted by
834 posts

My husband and I did as you did for Portugal and Slovenia/Croatia/Montenegro and it worked well for us. For this trip, you're trying to cover a lot of ground. You have a good chunk of time, so I think it's a good start. I'd certainly join you! That said, I would encourage to think about quality vs quantity. I think I'd break it into two trips, or, alternatively, drop 5 or 6 nights somewhere along the way (nights 29-34??) and add a day or two to some of your destinations, depending on your goals for each town. I don't think that you have adequately accounted for is the simple logistics. For example, how long does it take to pack up and travel from one destination to the next? (Bologna to Verona, for example.) Probably would need to factor in a half-day on the road, if not more, which of course decreases your actual time on the ground in each overnight location. Do you like to take a day now and then to stop and breathe? By that I mean to not have anything on your "must do today" schedule -- sleep in, do laundry, stretch out on a chaise and read at your agriturismo, whatever. For each overnight stop, you're listing a lot of day trips. I'm assuming you realize you can't do them all, but driving times alone will limit which ones you actually pick. Right now, your itinerary allows little/no time to enjoy the locations where you're staying. In Locorotondo area, it would be nearly impossible to cover all those destinations for day trips. One or two would be plenty. Even doing some of them, you'd leave only a little time for Locorotondo itself., not necessarily a bad thing as it's pretty small. We found that while places in southern Italy seem close together on the map, you need more time than you'd think to get around. Same for Lecce--a lot of day trips to accomplish for a short period in Lecce. You could easily spend two days in Lecce alone and pick one day trip. I haven't been to Bologna, but I have been to Ravenna, Parma, and Modena. Each deserves at least a full day. That leaves you no time in Bologna itself. You get the idea. I look forward to seeing how your itinerary develops.

Posted by
87 posts

@phred - Not a vacation, but it's a lot, I know. The trip covers a lot of ground like a Best of Italy tour. That's why I brought the full itinerary to this forum to get feedback. I've seen all sorts of itineraries and lengths of stay, on this and other forums. Recently retired, my husband and I are figuring out what works for us. I think he may prefer slow travel and to stay in one place longer, spoking out from there. I've begun to extend my fast travel to 3 or 4 nights at most stops. We're a travel work in progress. :-)

@acraven - Thanks for your feedback. It's often a challenge to find that balance of site-seeing, activities, and day trips. And, we've discovered that a good outdoor cafe or restaurant can derail the most well laid plans. :-)

We considered Sicily, but after viewing several YouTube videos, thought it might have a similar feel to Puglia and surrounding area and we wanted variety. (We loved having variety in Portugal!) That may not be the case at all. The original thinking was to do Sicily/Amalfi coast/Basilicata/Puglia in one trip and the Alps (Italian and Swiss) on another. Perhaps Bologna (and day trips) and Verona (and day trips) could fit nicely into the Alps trip? Also, I'll take a closer look ar Ravenna, etc.

Posted by
3644 posts

Positano doesn’t strike me as a good base for 4 nights. We found the town, itself, dull. There’s very little to see other than over-priced tourist magnet shops. There have been postings here about the buses from there being packed and the need for long waits. Imo, Amalfi makes a much better base.

I would shift a day or even 2 from Sorrento/ Amalfi Coast to the Verona segment. Padova merits a least a full day, as does Vicenza.

Posted by
1637 posts

"We considered Sicily, but after viewing several YouTube videos, thought it might have a similar feel to Puglia and surrounding area and we wanted variety. "

I just completed a trip that included Puglia and Sicily. They are very different. If you want to see Sicily you would definitely have to split your trip in two as Sicily deserves a minimum of two weeks. So many cultures included in one island.

Posted by
267 posts

Agree with Bob, as we just completed Puglia and Sicily also. Very different from each other. Both worth a visit. I like your original plan better.

Posted by
5648 posts

The spring and fall shoulder seasons are disappearing as such- the crowds are coming earlier and in greater numbers. If you are flexible, I'd recommend going earlier in the spring, such as April , a week after Easter break. We were in Sorrento this past mid-May, and Positano and Amalfi town were shoulder - shoulder crowded already.
Also- more time in Lake Como, the most beautiful place to relax!
Safe travels!

Posted by
567 posts

I think your trip sounds very doable and exciting, but I would suggest some tweaks. By the end of a long trip I would want a bit more relaxed feel. You have 3 two night stops at the end. I would add more nights to Lake Como and maybe combine your dolomite’s into one stay. I also feel you dedicated a lot of time to the Amalfi area with both Sorrento and Positano. Perhaps taking one or two nights from Positano would give you a bit more time for the north