I booked Best Western Plus Hotel Universo for 3 nights next month, it is a couple blocks from the station. The reviews were good, the price was attractive, and I like proximity for arrival/departure and day trip by train.
However, I'm waffling a bit. On my first (only) trip to Rome 5 years ago. I let my guard down while eating inside at the train station and managed to get my phone stolen, so I'm always aware of that. I blame myself for that, and didn't feel unsafe, just stupid. I literally had it on the table out in the open and someone came by and dropped like 100 pope postcards on the table, distracting me and taking my phone. I didn't even know it was missing for 30 minutes.
Have you stayed here or near the station? Thoughts? Did you feel safe? Gets dark early in November, and I do want to be able to comfortably walk to dinner or similar.