Please sign in to post.

Having second thoughts about Tuscany itinerary - should we try to add Chianti?

We are leaving for Italy in 2 weeks and now I'm starting to second guess my itinerary. I'm now wondering if I should drop a day trip to Perugia and Gubbio and add a day trip to Chianti via S222 from either Cortona or Montepulciano. We love food and wine but not necessarily winery tours - we'd much rather combine food with wine and not have to worry about driving which is why I planned 4 nights in Montepulciano so it's not about tasting wine it's more about the scenery. We enjoy wandering about smaller towns but have a limited interest in churches and museums which is why I'm thinking the day trip to Perugia and Gubbio is the most logical to drop. Our taste in art is definitely on the contemporary side so I'm pretty sure we will get our fill of history and historical art in Florence and Rome. Which brings me to the question of whether we should try and fit in the Chianti route for the scenery and the 'sense' of the region. The distance and timing to Greve is relatively similar from either Cortona or Montepulciano so it's quite doable to change things up. Here's what our trip looks like now:

Arrive in Rome in the afternoon (September 4) and take a train to Orvieto (3 nights and 2 days, one of which I'm sure will be a 'recovery' day). The next part of our itinerary looks like this:

Pick up car and drive to Cortona via Spoleto and Assisi. (4 nights & 3 days):

  • Day trip to Perugia & Gubbio
  • Spend the day in Cortona (market day)
  • Day trip to Arrezo

Drive to Montepulciano via Chiusi (4 nights; 3 days)

  • Explore Montepulciano
  • Day trip to Sienna
  • Day trip to Montalcino & Pienza

Drive to Lucca via Volterra & San Gimignano (drop car in Lucca) (3 nights; 2 days)

  • Explore Lucca
  • Train to Pisa

Train to Florence (4 nights; 3 days), Tuscan Coast bike tour (6 nights); Rome (5 nights; 4.5 days). Return home October 3.

What do you think - should we add Chianti and drop Perugia and Gubbio?

Posted by
8362 posts

Your itinerary is very much different from most Umbrian and Tuscan travelers--and somewhat refreshing. You have obviously done your homework about traveling slowly. Chianti is just a short distance SE of Florence.
But you are going to some.awfully quiet.places. I would cut one of the inland towns out and head for Cinque Terre

Posted by
792 posts

Cinque Terre? the most overrated tourist swamped place in all of Italy. Visit it in November

Posted by
11613 posts

I love Gubbio and Perugia, I would certainly not give up either one for Cinque Terre. Chianti is a bit tougher to call. I would go for Gubbio and Perugia, they each have different things to offer than other places you will visit.

Posted by
91 posts

I'm with Zoe. We spent an entire day in Gubbio and found it very interesting. Read up on the history and enjoy a non-touristy day. Don't miss the funicular (or whatever it's called) up the mountain.

Posted by
11613 posts

At the top of the mountain is the sanctuary of Sant'Ubaldo, Gubbio's patron saint. Read about the Festa dei Ceri before you go.

Gubbio is also known for ceramics.

Posted by
136 posts

Thanks everyone for your responses. We have deliberately omitted CT on this trip for several reasons, not least of which is the hordes of tourists.

Based on your feedback I've decided to leave the day trips from Cortona as they are. As our travel day from Cortona to Montepulciano was quite short with only a stop in Chiusi, I've added Montacino and Pienza. The driving time from Cortona - Montepulciano via these 3 towns is about 3 hours without stops. If we stop for 1 hour in each of Chiusi and Pienza and 2 hours in Montalcino that's a 7 hour day allowing for some flexibility depending on our whims that day. This revision gives us a full day to explore Chianti from Montepulciano. And as they say, no battle plan ever survives contact with the enemy, we treat our itinerary as a guideline and make changes as we go along.

Posted by
7175 posts

Oh, to have your dilemma.
I dare say you wrestled with adding a central Tuscan location around Siena, but opted for Cortona to allow excursions into Umbria. Your itinerary is so thorough that you will experience lots of countryside throughout your driving travels. Chianti is really just that, some more beautiful Tuscan countryside. If you are not particular wine buffs then I would leave things as is, they sound wonderful. Safe travels. Enjoy.

Posted by
136 posts

Yes, David we do like our wine, thus our interest in adding Chianti to the itinerary. And we have a fondness for driving through wine country so I'm glad we seem to have found a way to include Chianti. We've been in training for our trip by making sure we drink only Italian wines in the last few weeks...

Posted by
10408 posts

Your trip sounds good and your training impressive!! Have a great time.