Please sign in to post.

Florence + Tuscany

Hello everyone.

I am planning a 3 week trip to Italy with my mother this October. We were thinking of starting with Venice, followed by Verona and then make our way down to Tuscany before finishing our trip in Rome. Our itinerary is not set in stone.

I still haven't decided how long to stay in Tyscany, but it wil be at minimum 8 nights, 4 in the historic city of Florence and the rest to visit Tuscany. Every city and village seems beautiful, so we'll go wherever and do whatever will prevent us from wasting time. I have some questions :

  1. If Florence is a good base, should we rent a car or ride buses and trains? For those of you who know Tuscany well, what would you do in my shoes?

  2. If you had to choose a city or village as a base in Tuscany to visit the region, which one would you choose and why? We are open to go anywhere, so I'm interested in your opinions.

  3. Where else in Italy would you go if you wanted to fit in one or more places for this trip?

*Edit: categorical views and opinionated takes from people who know the area well are welome. That's what I'm looking for.

Posted by
8023 posts

You don’t need or want a car IN Florence but a car is almost necessary for visiting small towns in Tuscany.

We like the Pienza area for a stay with a car. Pienza is a flat hill town, compared to others (Siena, Montepulciano) which are very steep, hilly might be hard for your elderly mother.

Lucca is another flat town but a bit too far north and west for exploring the rest of Tuscany and you wouldn’t want a car there either - inside walls is all pedestrianized.

There are a lot of threads here that discuss exploring Tuscany. Use the Search function and filter by Date and Type

Info here as well
https://www.ricksteves.com/europe/italy

Posted by
3 posts

Thank you for the advice Christine! I'll look into Pienza.

I have read a lot of threads about Tuscany in the forum, but I haven't seen anyone share yet exactly what they would do. Most threads explore several possibilities and leave the reader with too many options. I'm interested in reading categorical views from people who know the region very well.

Posted by
8023 posts

I would spend 3 nights in Florence-no day trips
Then pick up a car and stay 1 or 2 places 2 or 3 nights somewhere near Siena or in Chianti and another 3 in Pienza

From those 2 locations you can explore each day by car
I could name all the little villages we like but you do gave to choose those yourself;)

After that I would drop the car take train to Rome for 5 or 6 nights - with maybe 1 day trip from Rome to Orvieto ( or stop on the way) or Tivoli

Posted by
8916 posts

Tuscany is filled with amazing medieval cities 700 years old.
Siena is wonderful. Lucca is worth a day. San Giminanco (SP), Cortona and Pisa.

Posted by
16643 posts

I’m with Christine. Stay 3 nights in Florence to see Florence only (maybe 4 nights if you want o to see Pisa+Lucca by train in a day trip). Then rent a car on your way out of Florence and stay in a base (or two) near Siena. Where exactly is up to you. Siena would work also as a base, but be aware of traffic restrictions in the city if you have a car. Lots of small villages or farmhouses (agriturismo) can be used too. There are lots of villages to visit in Tuscany, in virtually every one of the 10 provinces comprising Tuscany (these are the 10 provinces, named after the provincial capital cities: Florence, Siena, Arezzo, Prato, Pistoia, Lucca, Pisa, Massa-Carrara, Grosseto, Livorno).
Some resources on the many villages of Tuscany are below.

https://www.borghiditoscana.net/en/
https://borghipiubelliditalia.it/en/toscana/