Please sign in to post.

First Time in Italy in September - Where to make our base?

We are going to Italy late September for the first time. We have no desire to be in super crowded, over touristy areas. We are willing to miss Rome, Florence, Venice, etc. My husband is chronically ill and has no desire to spend his dream vacation pushing through lines. He would prefer to be in Tuscany.

Where would be a good base? We will fly into Rome, but can do a layover or train from there. We would like to rent an apartment for 8-10 days and do some full or half day trips. We would like a medium sized city with inexpensive food options, accessibility to the train, and much to do within 1 hour. We are going to experience the culture. We speak very little Italian. We were originally thinking Pisa because there is so much within 1 hour, but then we looked at the cruise ship schedule. What about Prato or Lucca? Is there another city that is a hidden gem? Would a small village be better? Thanks!

Posted by
4600 posts

We stayed in Lucca for a little over a week in September (2011) because it offered enough to do when we stayed in town on various days: lovely churches (some with evening concerts,) a tower with a view, lovely square with restaurant options, old city wall for a stroll, small city gardens, shopping, etc. It is all very easily walkable. It was not overly crowded when we visited, though that may have changed since 2011. More recent visitors can give you better guidance on that.

It was easy to get to other places by train: 30 minutes to Pisa, about 45 to Florence (you could do a day trip, if you wanted.) We rented a car (in Lucca) for a few days to visit Cinque Terre, Carrara, Vinci.

We stayed inside the wall, near the southeast side, which is nearest the train station - a 10 or 15 minute walk or a very short taxi ride. It was very quiet in that area.

Posted by
1580 posts

Pienza is a great location for a base. You will have an opportunity to spend a day in Montepulciano. San Gimignano/Volterra would also be a great day trip. Arezzo as well would be a find base. Find a winery and do a food and wine pairing for lunch or dinner. Even Cortona is within reach.

The links below are Tuscany accommodation suggestions like Hotel L' Antico Pozzo and some Agriturismos in the area that can make your stay very comfortable:

https://www.anticopozzo.com/en/

http://www.poderemarcampo.com/agriturismo-podere-marcampo-volterra/

https://www.relaiscortebenedetto.it/en/

https://www.agriturismoilcasalino.it/en-us

For cooking Tuscany cooking classes visit this site:

http://divinacucina.com/

Posted by
34 posts

We chose Florence as a base when we went last December. We did that mostly based on the places we wanted to see and the fact that later in the year the weather can be challenging at time. We would look at the weather and then decide based on our list what we were going to go to see. If it was raining in Florence but better to the west we would head out to Pisa/Lucca and so on. The great thing about Florence is there is so much to see there, if it's raining everywhere (which it did when we were there) we would head to one of Florence's great churches or museums. You may want to decide what you are interested in seeing though and perhaps let that influence your decision on the central location. I do think it's a good idea to stay somewhere there are some 'A' list things you want to see. That way if the weather isn't good or you just don't feel like travelling you can see something within a reasonable walk.

Posted by
4105 posts

Lucca would make a great base for this area. There's plenty to see and do. There are many easy day trips from here by train & bus. If you don't plan on renting a car. See if these would be of interest.

Barga. Train 45min. Montecatini Terme/Alto train 28 min. Pistoia. Train 40 min. Montecarlo.
Train 1 hr. Pisa. Train 31 min. Viareggio. Train 27 minutes but also easily combined with Pisa.
Torre del Largo. Bus 53 min. Bango di Lucca.
Bus 44 min.

Posted by
27093 posts

It makes a great deal of difference whether you are willing to rent a car for at least part of the time. Basing in a small, hidden-gem sort of place may not work well at all if you are depending on public transportation.

I recommend getting a comprehensive guide book for Tuscany and making a list of places you'd like to see. Don't worry if it's way too long for the time you have available (as it almost certainly will be). You just need a subset of those places that's large enough to fill your time.

Florence is the transportation hub for Tuscany. It's also the origination point for most of the day-tours. Before committing to spend your time elsewhere, verify the availability of transportation to a good number of the places on your target list. Checking on trains is relatively easy; I like to use the Deutsche Bahn website, though you won't see fares there. I recommend staying in a town with rail service if you don't plan to rent a car. Total dependence on buses will slow you down.

For destinations without train stations, you can begin exploring transportation options on the Rome2Rio website. Unfortunately, you cannot trust its travel times, frequencies or fares, but if it says there's a bus, there usually is. You can just keep clicking through the website until you find the name of the bus company, usually accompanied by a link to its website. That's where you can check on the actual schedule. Be careful about day of the week; often there's not much happening on Sundays and holidays.

Posted by
4573 posts

If willing to go beyond Tuscany, Bologna is a great hub. But for smaller towns that cover similar area, think of using Ferrera.

Posted by
367 posts

I agree that Lucca is a great hub. I've been there 4x, but only because my husband is from there. I usually talk it down because I don't want it to get overridden and I'm selfish and want to keep it to myself, but really, it's pretty fabulous. Great place to hang out. Also, very accessible to the sites of Florence and Pisa, and if you want the beach, Viareggio--all by easy train. And, it's close to the Garfagnana, which I think is an untouristed gem. If you have a car, Volterra and San Gimignano are easy day trips well worth taking.

With your criteria though, I think you have lots of options.

Posted by
11315 posts

Take a look at Sinalunga. It is not far from Siena, Arezzo, Cortona, Montepulciano, and more.

Posted by
1386 posts

We only spent the day there, but we were pretty enchanted by Pistoia in late September 2017. It's halfway between Lucca and Florence on the train. Something like 40 minutes to each. Definitely not over-touristed. Hardly even touristed. But lots of interesting striped churches, museums and art galleries, good food, and a farmer's market. I don't think it's at all hilly, either.

Posted by
396 posts

Lucca is a good place. Flat, not hilly. Lots to see and do. Pistoia is also a good recommendation. Less touristy than Lucca and also a good location. have a wonderful trip!