On June 5, 2025, we're staying atop Brunate in Lake Como for 3 nights then traveling to Tirano to catch the Bernina Express to Chur. It looks like renting a car and driving is our best bet (84 miles, 2 hours). I've never driven in Italy before. Are my New York driver's license and passport enough? I need an automatic transmission, assume that won't be a problem. Is it also possible to hire a driver to take us to Tirano? Any suggestion, advice are greatly appreciated.
One option is a ferry to Varenna, where you can catch a train to Tirano. ( I think there's some track work currently, but not by June.)
You need an international drivers permit, easily secured from AAA.
Italy is not the best experience for a first time driver, based on reports here of unexpected tickets arriving months after your trip.
I'm sure others will chime in.
Have a great trip.
https://community.ricksteves.com/travel-forum/italy/international-drivers-license-required
I do not know if there is a rental agency in Tirano to return the car; please check, it is not a big city. Also, do not assume an automatic won't be a problem.
The easiest train itinerary is Como San Giovanni-Monza-Tirano, it takes 3h 15min.
How much is a car service from Como to Tirano, Italy? Any recommendations?