I requested a quote from both Auto Europe and Aesserent. Auto Europe's price is about 30% lower than Aesserent. I have read that Aesserent is directly across from the train station and the staff are very helpful and accommodating. Those things are important, but maybe not worth 30% more to me.
So...., if anybody has picked up a rental car in Chiusi, from either of these companies, I would love to hear if you were satisfied. Are Auto Europe's prices really that good or am I going to pay for "extras" when I pick up the car?