We just decided this weekend to take an anniversary trip to Italy in May 2014 for about 16 - 18 days (May 13-May 30 or so). We thought about a RS Tour or even the My Way option to have someone else do the planning, but want more flexibility to do the trip than a tour allows. Can we reasonably expect to plan the trip and get reservations, etc (using some back door recommendations) during the high season if we haven't even started yet?
Hubby never met a cathedral or historic site he didn't like, and I like nature/scenery and quiet relaxing. Thinking about South to North so we get hit Rome at the beginning when we are fresher, and end our trip with some relaxing downtime. Itinerary we are thinking about: Rome - 3 nights; Sienna area - 3 nights; Florence 2-nights; Cinque Terre - 3 nights; Venice -2 nights; Lakes 2-3 nights and fly home out of Milan. We have some flexibility to add a day or two beyond this and/or increase by a night at places we should stay longer.
Would appreciate the thoughts from some experienced Italian travelers!