Please sign in to post.

Bistecca alla Fiorentina Question

Can anyone confirm the response I received from AI regarding the optimum size/weight of steak that I should order for 2 average eaters. This was the response I received from AI: *"Most restaurants in Tuscany have a minimum order of 1kg. For two people, you should order 1 to 1.3 kilograms (about 2.2 to 2.8 pounds) of Bistecca alla Fiorentina.

Posted by
7048 posts

Sounds about right. Those Tbone or porterhouse steaks are THICK! Usually around 2" or more. You just can't get a tbone steak of that thickness for less than a kg. And dont forget that includes the bone, which can account for up to a quarter of the weight.

And while you didn't ask, the bistecca we has on our last visit was positively blissful. I would have gnawed on the bone if we hadn't been in a restaurant.

Posted by
17527 posts

It has to be at least 800 grams to be considered a "Fiorentina" but typically it's always over 1 kg (maybe 1.2kg).

It has to be about 4 to 6cm thick for the perfect "rare" cooking (so 5cm or 2 inches is the average). That is appropriate for 2 people, actually my wife and I can hardly finish it (and I'm above average eater), so I wish I could have a 3rd person to share it with.

It's a lot, basically, even net of the bone, you are looking at more than 1 pound of meat per person.

Posted by
8611 posts

Your server will likely also help to find a reasonable cut from their available inventory that night. The meat will be brought to your table, raw, for inspection and approval before it’s cooked.

Posted by
249 posts

Thank you, everyone -- your confirmation is much appreciated! Yes, that is going to be a lot of meat for two. Maybe we can find a dog to share it with (LOL). Very weird "posts" at the end there. Never had that happen before.