Please sign in to post.

Bank- best exchange rate

Which bank in Italy do you think offers the best exchange rate?

Posted by
3220 posts

An "exchange rate" is purchasing their currency with your dollars, and as this is a purchase, it will involve a profit for the seller, somewhere between 5 and 10%.
What you need to do is withdraw money from your own account via an ATM, bank owned, that does not charge fees or markups, Poste Italiane comes to mind. And unless you have allowed the transaction to be calculated in $$s, you should get your transaction should be less than 1% of the posted international currency rates.Hopefully your account is with bank that does not charge Foreign Transaction Fees (that is yet another 3% lost), does not charge for other ATM usage, and refunds any foreign ATM usage fees (Schwab and Fidelity immediately come to mind)

Posted by
2284 posts

The exchange rate of your money will be at the current bank rate by your home bank - which is a good one. It's the fees and charges that add up. As noted use an ATM physically attached to real bank to avoid local charges but home banks will usually charge you a "foreign exchange fee" of usually about 3% and possibly a "not our ATM" fee as well. You can check with your bank or credit union but these fees are pretty standard. Fidelity and Schwab have debit cards attached to brokerage accounts that don't have exchange fees and will pay back ATM charges.

Always refuse to let the ATM (or credit card machines) convert to dollars for you before the transaction. They will give you a terrible rate that will cost you more than you'll ever want.

I like to carry and use cash more than most people - on both sides of the Atlantic - so it was worth it for me to get one of the cards without fees. But if you use a usual amount of cash the fees associated with an ATM withdrawal or two aren't going to affect your vacation budget that much.

Have a great trip,
=Tod

Posted by
9685 posts

Likely, no bank in Italy will exchange currency for you if you are not a customer.

Taking cash to exchange will give you a very poor rate, especially if you use an exchange bureau in the airport or tourist areas (or for that matter anywhere)

How much are you trying to exchange? and for what purpose?

Posted by
2284 posts

@Paul makes a good point. If you were asking about money changing bringing dollars to change into euros that's not really a thing anymore. There are a few money changers - usually at airports - still around but you will get a terrible rate and fees. You might as well do it at home and get that terrible rate instead rather than spend vacation time looking for a money change place. I think some special Wells Fargos in the US have foreign currency if you're an account holder there.

You should instead just use your ATM card and get euros while you are there.

=Tod

Posted by
30722 posts

I checked out a Poste Italian bancomat (ATM) a few months ago in northern Italy--probably in Milan. It was going to charge me 5 euros on a withdrawal of around 100 euros, so I walked. I also found banks charging 3 euros and 5 euros.

It is increasingly hard to find no-fee ATMs in Italy. It is probably still possible if you're willing to try every ATM you see (using precious vacation time), but for the typical tourist needing not much cash, it's not worth the effort. Now, if you can find very current online information pointing to a particular bank whose bancomats don't charge fees, that's a different story.

Posted by
18355 posts

The best thing you can do is to pay with credit card (Apple Pay, Google Pay) wherever you can, so that you minimize having to pull out cash out of a bank ATM machine and be charged fees on both ends (your bank and the local bank). You will need some hard cash sometimes, like to pay for the turnstile at a public restroom or just for very small purchases, but if you use your credit card as much as you possibly can, so that you won’t need more than $100 or even $200 in hard cash, you will come ahead and whatever exchange fees you pay for that amount of currency exchange won’t matter much in the context of the whole trip which will certainly cost you thousands.

Also, when using your credit card, the card terminal, reading that your card is US issued, might ask you if you want to be charged in US dollars. Always decline that offer! Make sure you are always charged in the local currency (the €uro)

Posted by
346 posts

@Roberto Da Firenze-“ You will need some hard cash sometimes, like to pay for the turnstile at a public restroom or just for very small purchases”
I had to laugh at this part, because, last month when we were on our one night layover in Amsterdam, there were public toilets that only accepted cards, and not coins. After I exited the toilet I noticed that my Italian wife was still standing in front of the machine trying to figure out where to feed the coins into it. I pointed to where it said “card only, no coins” and tapped the machine with my card. We had a good laugh about that.