Next summer, I am spending a week in Italy with some friends for my 50th birthday. I have narrowed it down to 3 possible rentals. One in Todi, one in Sarteano, and the last in Semproniano. I really went back and forth between staying in the countryside and staying in a town. Ultimately I decided that walkability to restaurants, shops/markets, etc. took priority to views.
I am wondering if anyone has thoughts on one or more of these towns. We will have a rental car for the week. We'll do a combination of day trips and staying in town, a combination of eating out and preparing meals in our rental. Thanks for the help!