My fiance and I are trying to plan a honeymoon in Italy in Sept., but there are so many amazing places and we only have 10 nights available. We enjoy culture (art, theater, and great food), as well as nature (esp. hiking) - and still want the honeymoon feel. So far we are thinking to definitely do Venice and Florence, but also want to add a third leg of the trip. Do you guys recommend: Verona, Cinque Terre, Milan w/ Lake Como? We think we would also love Amalfi Coast/Capri, but it seemed like maybe this is something we should do for an anniversary trip later with Rome?
We have guide books, and I've done so much research - so I'm just looking for honest opinions. I'm sure the entire country is magical - but if you had to pick an itinerary - what would you do?