Nine days in Peloponnese--Help?

We are renting a car for a trip to the Peloponese in May from Athens Car Rental and got a very good price if you want to check them out.

We will be in the Peloponese for 16 nights so twice as long as you. A few comments.

I would not stay in Kalamata. We are staying 3 nights in Pilos because I thought it involved the least driving for day trips and then one night in Koroni. I would decide what you want to see and use that to decide where to stay. Koroni is probably most charming but for what we wanted to see, we decided it wasn’t centrally located enough.

We are staying in both Kardamyli and Aeropoli and in my research it is Kardamyli that has hiking.

Montemvasia is a ways. Maybe eliminate if want to avoid driving?

Since you don't particularly enjoy wandering through villages and shops, I agree with BethFL that Kalamata isn't the right base for you. It's a large city, not a village, and not representative of the Peloponnese, which, in principle, isn't a region where one goes to see typical urban environments (the same goes for Sparta and Tripoli).

You don't want to drive long distances, but Pylos is even further from Athens than Delphi (and via a route with many more winding roads). Although all the roads are in excellent condition and very safe, this also means more driving time and less time for sightseeing and hiking.

Given the limited time you have, I don't see how you could also plan a detour to Montemvasia.

On this map you'll find some ideas for visits and hikes.

https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1HzqyEorKrUZxc5LjPjlvG2utnKof78E&usp=sharing

Thanks much. I felt Kalamata was a good base, and near to Messini at least. I don't expect it to be charming, but we have dietary requirements, so we want to maximize our options by staying in a bigger town. It will also shorten the driving the following day.
I was thinking of the hike up to the Profitis Ilias Church in Areopoli, but if there isn't much else there, we can skip it. Sorry for my lack of enthusiasm, this week was an add-on to a late March trip because my husband wanted to see Greece (he's never been).

I understand the distance from Athens to Pilos is far, but it is integrated to a circuit that sort of starts in Nafplion, if that makes sense. I see the road may be a bit scary to Pilos, but I have to live with some of that. I'm fine with curves, it's steep cliffs I have a problem with. Thanks for the link to that map, it's really great. I will save it.

So we are not going so Sparti, I mentioned it the route through which we would head toward Monemvasia. You say I don't have time; are we talking about the same place? I ask because transliterated spellings have already created some confusion for me! It is only 2,5 hrs from Kalamata. I have tried to maintain a pretty limited geography I think. I prefer not to stay only one night in a place, but we might stay one night down in that area. Could you recommend a place on the way back north to stop for the last night?

Thanks.

I stayed in a nice Greek Town called Petalidi on the right side of the left finger of the Peloponnese. It was a good base to explore Pylos, Methoni and Koroni.

Also a good base to get to Messini and a more relaxed Greek Vibe than Kalamata.

Another option is Gythio on the middle finger. Lovely town with a long waterfront, lovely back streets in Greek Neighborhoods, and lots of options for services. Also a good base to explore the Mani, Mystras and Monemvasia.

Also a lot easier to get to from Nafplio.

If interested you can check out a trip report with reports I did of one of my trips to the Peloponnese that may help with decisions.

FYI: Most of the roads anywhere in Greece are good whether in the mountains, coastline or driving through villages.

They are only dangerous ifyou drive dangerously.
https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g189483-i1277-k14200587-Peloponnese_Trip_Report_Sept_25_Oct_12-Peloponnese.html

You are right that there is a fast route to Monemvasia. It never occurred to me to go north to pick up the tollway which you can do. There is a route through the mountains which is more scenic but certainly something you would want to avoid if you don't like steep scary roads. I found this on a travel site.

The Fastest Route (Via Highway & Sparta)
This is the most efficient and comfortable option for 2026, utilizing the modern toll road network.
Route: Kalamata → A7 Motorway (towards Tripoli) → Lefktro interchange → A71

One difficulty with Monemvasia is that you really have to go to the center of the peninsula to get back to Athens as there is no main road up the coast. It looks like it is four hours (you really need to add to these estimations though so I would think more like 5). If you want to be closer, you could drive to Cornith.

edit: to add what Tommy said, you might want to go to Gytheo rather than Kalamata and see that part of the Peloponese instead. It would be less driving and still lots to see.

I'm in the weird position of having a day and no good way to use it. Yea, it was Google maps that sent me north to pick up 71. I found that frustrating at first! OK, wow. There is no way it is worth driving all the way down to Monemvasia (which I only know about because people online talk about "you have to go there") to spend a couple of hours walking around the old town. Kastania Caves are off the table because it would be close to 3 hrs of driving on scary roads to spend a couple of hours at the caves. Thank you Beth, for the detail about the roads; now I see why JoLui called Monemvasia a detour!

Total shift. Now we are looking into maybe one night in Pilos, then drive up the coast to Olympia, through Patras to Delphi (LOL) and back to Athens.

Sorry if I'm having trouble understanding your logic, but with this new shift, you'll be spending about 50% more time driving.

You can do it that way, but keep in mind that you're defining many destinations that might be "must-sees" but are very far apart.

Olympia, Delphi, are just places where you'll only spend a few hours among other tourists and you'll be driving for hours to get there.
So, in fact, you'll mainly be visiting the Peloponnese through a windshield. If that's okay with you, that's fine.

Also notethat archaeological sites close earlier during this season, typically around 3 or 4 PM at the latest.

I am confused too. The route I copied for you is further miles wise but faster and less difficult driving. There are tollways in Greece and driving on them is usually more efficient time wise even if further miles-wise.

We are spending the night in monemvasia in the old town. So you could do that too. You also could visit Mystras the next day.

OLympia is very crowded. We are skipping it. We saw Nemea when we visited Nafplio which you could do also if you add a night to Nafplio. Two nights isn’t very long. And you are doing even more driving.