Please sign in to post.

Rothenburg AND Regensburg ???

I am in the rough draft stage of a trip for Apr/May, 2022, including Germany and Salzburg. All travel is by train.

I have read great things about the town of Regensburg, so want to spend a day there, on the way to Rothenburg, [where I've been before,] and just love. RS doesn't include Regensburg in his guide books, but RS usually focuses on the "must see" areas, many of which I've been to. BUT- is Regensburg different enough from Rothenburg?

What do you wise and trusted advisors recommend?
Thanks so much!

Posted by
21166 posts

While Rothenburg is pretty much a tourist town, famous over the world for its preserved architecture, Regensburg is a real working city with a Unesco World Heritage old town.

Attached picture of famous building mural of David & Goliath. Note tour guide and gaggle of tourists taking photos.

https://www.google.com/maps/@49.02021,12.09656,3a,75y,8.83h,127.39t/data=!3m8!1e1!3m6!1sAF1QipP0FM4DmlkUbA4476qkkO26104c47yoKv5PID7Q!2e10!3e11!6shttps:%2F%2Flh5.googleusercontent.com%2Fp%2FAF1QipP0FM4DmlkUbA4476qkkO26104c47yoKv5PID7Q%3Dw203-h100-k-no-pi0-ya0.20022891-ro0-fo100!7i6912!8i3456

Posted by
106 posts

also looking at these 2 cities
but not sure easy to get to by train from
munich or nuremberg?
this would be for november travel

Posted by
21166 posts

Frequent direct regional trains to Regensburg from Munich or Nuremberg. Rothenburg is at least 2 train changes at Ansbach and Steinach.

https://www.bahn.com/en

Posted by
1528 posts

We are planning a trip in April 22 as well. We have been to Rothenburg and Regensburg many times before and will return. Regensburg is larger than Rothenburg. It has a university, a major medieval cathedral, and a wonderful old town core. If I had to choose, I would visit Regensburg. Both are great to our taste. Gary

Posted by
7072 posts

"...Rothenburg is pretty much a tourist town..."

Probably the single most touristy town in Germany for its size. In the linked article below, Rick himself acknowledges that "...Rothenburg is well on its way to becoming a medieval theme park." Towns with UNESCO WH zones and buildings (like Regensburg, Bamberg, Würzburg, Trier and others) are very worthwhile but mostly lack the tourist swarms and the tourist-vibe (and the Schneeball and Christmas ornament shops) that dominate Rothenburg's small street grid. The UNESCO towns get tourists of course, but their inhabitants are involved in all kinds of enterprises, whereas Rothenburg exists almost exclusively for the sake of tourism (which employs nearly everyone who works there.)

https://www.ricksteves.com/watch-read-listen/read/articles/germanys-fairytale-dream-town-rothenburg

Some of Rothenburg is well preserved, but a lot of it is pretty new. During WW II, most important towns and cities were bombed harshly, while less significant places were far less impacted. There are places you can go where damages were nil or very minor (Hannoversch Münden, which boasts more than 700 historic half-timbered buildings, comes to mind.) But Rothenburg was one of those less important places that actually got hit pretty hard - nearly half of the town you see today had to be reconstructed from wartime rubble. I've read that Rothenburg got targeted just because Hitler had popularized it as the "most German" of German towns.

Posted by
5620 posts

Thanks to all, I think we will do both cities, as Rothenburg will be at the end of our first week of travel, and will be a day of rest. Then- onto to the Rhine /Moselle River Valleys.
I learn so much here, I do appreciate the time and energy to respond.
Safe travels to all!

Posted by
1389 posts

I will echo Russ here some... There are tourists in Regensburg, but the city does not survive on them like Rothenburg ob der Tauber. Regensburg population is @150,000, Rothenburg @11,000. If you want to see a normal German city with the Old Town center a UNESCO site, than definitely Regensburg. Fantastic churches in Regensburg. The Danube rive flows thru Regensburg. Regensburg was bombed too (Messerschmitt factories), but was primarily outside the city and nothing like the damage to Nürnberg or Schweinfurt. History here before Roman occupation, merchant towers, thru the Battle of Ratisbon with Napoleon etc. I recommend Regensburg. Take some time and look into the history. FYI not much to see there, but there was an Kelten Oppidum about 10k from Rothenburg across the Tauber by Burgstall. https://www.kelten-creglingen-finsterlohr.de/Das-Oppidum/

Posted by
7304 posts

If you loved Rothenburg and would like something new, Bamberg is worth visiting as well! Easy day trip from Nürnberg, or you can stay there.

Posted by
7162 posts

One day in Regensburg is sufficient. The historic center isn’t that large. The town was heavily bombed in WWII because there was a ball bearing factory there. If you visit, go to Wurstkuchl sausage restaurant. It is supposedly the oldest restaurant in Germany, but take cash. When we were there in 2015 (on a Viking cruise) it didn’t accept credit cards. Also, many river cruise boats stop in Regensburg and on the mornings they are in port there are tourist groups all over the place. Afternoons and evenings are best for walking around.

Posted by
9222 posts

The cathedral in Regensburg is magnificent, one of the most beautiful I have seen, as well as very, very old.
The Thurn & Taxi palace has a lovely Christmas market and is worth seeing just on its own.
Regensburg has some wonderful Roman ruins as well as old Jewish sites.
As a history buff, I found the city to have plenty to explore and see.

Posted by
226 posts

We have been to both and plan to return to Regensburg this December for the Christmas Markets. We were there in Dec. 2019 for only one night and decided we wanted to return as we had little sightseeing time. I had just finished reading "The Guest Book" and learned about the "stumbling stones". There is a project to replace cobblestones with bronze stones with the names of Jews who were taken away. In Regensburg, we walked down several streets and happened upon them. A poignant moment. They were placed outside the former residents' homes. Rothenburg is very nice but ,sadly, very touristy. I would like to return to Rothenburg but it is not convenient if traveling by train.

Posted by
9222 posts

As an FYI, the Stumble Stones - Stolper Stein, are all over Europe and can be installed for anyone who was killed by the Nazis, not just Jews. They are installed for Jews, Socialists, Communists, Jehovah Witnesses, Homosexuals, People of Color, Roma/Sinti, T-4 Euthanasia Victims, and many, many others.

Presently, they are in 24 countries and there are over 80,000 of them.
http://www.stolpersteine.eu/en/home/