Please sign in to post.

Public Trans (Trains and busses) in Germany Dec

My childhood BFF and I are flying to Germany in a couple weeks for the Christmas Markets.

We only decided to finally just do it in the last month or so. We have plane tickets and hotel reservations but I have some logistic questions
 
• We won't be renting a car but rather relying on trains/public transport/walking.  Are the trains really that bad in Germany as far as being late/and or cancelled?
• Given the train situation - Is the following itinerary too ambitious for 10 nights (11 days)? -We could still adjust some of the hotels & itinerary if needed. - We are flying in and out of Frankfurt and start with- 2 nights Cologne, 2 nights Esslingen, 3 nights Gengenbach (as hotels were more affordable as a base for Strasbourg and other places), was supposed to be 3 nights Frankfurt and day trips - but my friend wanted to break it up into 1 night Heidelberg, 1 night Nuremberg and last night Frankfurt. 

• We are looking at getting 7 (or 10? )Day flexi /twin pass from DB. Any advice on this or other flexible /value public transport.

Posted by
431 posts

The general issues with DB are with the long-distance trains. It's best to avoid long journeys which involve more than one IC or ICE service with tight connections. The journeys you're talking about should be possible with a single long-distance train and maybe a regional connection afterwards.

Posted by
8436 posts

FRA > Cologne > Esslingen > Gengenbach > Heidelberg > Nuremberg > FRA

You have 6 trips for sure. And with the GRP pass you are golden. Ride any trains you like at any hour. Take detours. Make unplanned outings if you like... With the pass you can hop on the first ICE train you find going to Cologne on Day 1 and not have to worry about missing a train you pre-reserved and losing your $ (on a pre-purchased ticket in the event you have a flight/security/baggage delay.)

I'd get the 7-day flexi-twin pass. Use the extra day for the unspecified day trip you will take from Gengenbach to... (Freiburg? Basel?) For the trip to Strasbourg, it's regional trains only and you will have a KONUS card from your hotel in G'bach that gets you to Kehl (German border town) and back but you will also need a Europass 24h Mini ticket which will cover both of you on the tracks from Kehl to Strasbourg (and back.) Buy it on the day of travel (there are ticket machines at the station in Gengenbach) and hang onto it throughout the day.

https://www.ortenaulinie.de/,Lde/startseite/fahrkarten/europass.html

Any smaller trips you might make should be done by local day pass or with your KONUS card from Gengenbach on the regional trains. The cost will be minimal.

Posted by
4286 posts

The trains aren't that bad. It is just that people used to them being better. One advantage you have in Germany is that DB runs a lot of trains, and you can take another train without much fuss if a delay makes you miss a train. I travel through Germany quite regularly, and I have never not arrived at my destination. I occasionally end up half an hour later then expected home.

So just avoid the last trains of the day. Start your travel early. Then just go. You'll get there. Might be with a delay, but you'll get there.

(Other railways manage to be more punctual by running as few trains as possible. DB is not like that.)

Posted by
28100 posts

DB is doing great. On long distance runs only about a third are late. On the local trains it’s only a bit more than 1 in 10 that runs late. But the standards for being on time are strict. A 6-minute delay is “late”.

Airlines generally are given 15 minutes before they are counted as late which is why most airlines do 90%+ on time rates.

So, on average how late are the trains? I can’t find where anyone is talking on that number.

Posted by
8436 posts

Is the following itinerary too ambitious for 10 nights

It is doable, as we've pretty much pointed out. But I should add that my answer to THIS question is probably "yes, too ambitious," unless you care only about Christmas markets - and only care specifically about the aforementioned markets.

  • Getting around to all these relatively distant places is both time-consuming and expensive.

  • Christmas markets are almost EVERYWHERE in Germany. I just consulted my AI buddy and discovered that my statement is pretty accurate, at least as it refers to a 50-mile radius in the Frankfurt/Rhine-Main region... Here's what it told me...

If you're staying near Frankfurt Airport in December, you can
realistically choose from about 50 Christmas-market towns within a
50-mile drive, ranging from major city markets to small historic
village markets.

And it provided a list of the more prominent market-mentions in this region too:

Frankfurt am Main
Mainz
Wiesbaden
Darmstadt
Offenbach
Hanau
Bad Homburg
Kronberg
Königstein
Idstein
Rüdesheim am Rhein
Eltville
Seligenstadt
Langen
Bad Soden
Kelkheim
Friedrichsdorf
Karben
Schwalbach
Sulzbach
Aschaffenburg (near the edge of the radius)
Bensheim (near the edge of the radius)

How flexible are you about your plans?

  • The towns you have chosen to stay in of course have other things to see and do besides Christmas markets. But in this respect, they are no different from the Rhine-Main region towns. Even if you never set foot in a Christmas market, you would not find yourselves bored in these places. It's just that the wider English-language media sources fail to report well on these places, and as a result the place names are unknown to us Anglophones.

  • Unknown / lesser-known towns and cities IME tend to feel much more local and more "German" than the big-name destinations. This applies to their Christmas markets too. And of course at the markets, you'll have fewer international tourists cluttering your path as you move from stand to stand.

  • A tighter travel radius would mean travel only on regional trains (which have better on-time performance records) rather than long-distance trains, which would also eliminate a need for pricey rail passes and tickets And it would qualify you for Deutschland-Tickets (€60+ each; one D-Ticket covers any/all train rides for the entire month of December.) With the D-Tickets you have total flexibility and are free from the task of scheduling/prepurchasing multiple tickets/making seat reservations.

https://www.seat61.com/train-travel-in-germany.htm#Deutschlandticket

  • You might do fine with just 1 or 2 different hotel locations instead with a tightening of your travel radius.
Posted by
3203 posts

Well, on my trip in Sept., 2 trains were cancelled at the first stop. For one the entire track in my direction was closed. I had to get a cab to get to the next big station. I think every other train was late, but not enough to be a problem. Just make sure that you leave yourself time if you need to connect to an IC or ICE train

Thete is a direct ICE train from Offenbach to FRA. There are several trains from Gengenbach to Offenburg and I took an earlier one to make sure I was there in plenty of time for the ICE. Not really necessary since the ICE train was late, but it eliminates anynworry.

If you take ICE trains, you should purchase the tickets ASAP to save on the price. I recommend purchasing seat reservations.