Please sign in to post.

Munich to FRA early April

My husband and I are flying into Munich the morning of 3/31 and out of FRA on 4/10. My original plan was to spend a couple of days in Germany and then head over to Strasbourg, France to explore the Alsace region. I tend to research things to death and have a difficult time committing to a plan because there might be something better and I need to keep planning and looking. So, at this point all I have booked are the flights and a hotel in Strasbourg that I can easily cancel.

The decision I'm having the most difficult time with is using trains or renting a car. Last year in April, we relied on trains for Paris, Belgium, and Holland; I'm familiar with Eurail and buying passes and have read up on the 49 Euro monthly pass in Germany. On the last trip, we spent a lot of time in museums. We like to bike, hike, see beautiful old places, and eat good food (not 5 star fancy people though). Driving a car seems like a good choice to give us more freedom to pull over and do these sorts of things and to see more than tourist traps; however, I'm worried that we'll be stuck in a car the entire time and not like that. I planned on spending a couple of days in Salzburg and driving or taking a bus over to the highest peak via a cog train, seeing Augsburg, Colmar, and other smaller historical towns in Alsace. Recently though, I've learned about the Rhine Valley and its castles. This has me thinking maybe we should just stay in Germany and skip France this time. I'd like to skip recent historical points of interest and focus on the old world.

I'm looking for quite a bit of advice here so I'll break it down into numbers and want to thank you for even reading this far.

  1. Can we use the trains and busses as easily as a car for the experiences we're looking for?
  2. Alsace for 4 days or Rhine Valley?
  3. Maybe skip Austria for Rhine Valley?

Thank you

Posted by
99 posts

Car Rental through Auto Europe picking the car up at Hertz with no deductible is 388.00 (economy class) which includes 71.28 for the car drop off in Frankfurt. Take the train to Salzburg and pick up the car at the airport on the way back. Save two car rental days and the big hassle of parking.

Driving this vacation is quite good in fact driving Germany here is excellent. You should have clear sailing tourists really haven’t arrived yet. It is a tight vacation, but you can see both Salzburg and Strasbourg and the Alsace region.

Flight into Munich 3/31/24
3/31 leaving Salzburg 4/2: Munich to Salzburg for 2 nights. On 4/2 take an early morning train back to the Airport in Munich and get your car. The car pickup is at the Hertz desk is on the first floor at the top of the escalator from your exit of the train.

4/2 The drive to Rothenburg is 2 hours and 10 minutes. 1 night
4/3 Leaving Rothenburg: The drive to Colmar from Rothenburg is 3:10 minutes. Staying in Colmar for 4 nights (until 4/7) The first day is a short day so stay and explore Colmar. The second day take a train to Strasbourg and avoid all the hassle due to the car environmental issues and car tags needed. Now you have 2 days to go to Riquewihr, Kayersberg, Ribeauville or you might want to go back to Strasbourg, your choice. Been to these towns, in fact we were there this Christmas and just love them.

4/7 and 4/8: I would drive to Rüdesheim, which is a 3-hour drive. Stay there 2 nights and on 4/9 in the afternoon head on over to Frankfurt airport (about 1 hour and 30 minutes) and stay at one of the airport hotels. Real easy to drop your car off. Done it many times.

Posted by
6644 posts

Driving a car seems like a good choice to give us more freedom to pull
over and do these sorts of things and to see more than tourist traps

Traveling to tourist traps is done routinely by both train and car - by tourists who don't know any better.

Avoiding tourist traps is not difficult by train. The German Rail system was designed for mainly Germans, not for tourists, and it connects towns and cities of importance in everyday German life.

With about 10 days, and with MUC at one end and FRA at the other, I can see extending that travel zone for stays in 1) Salzburg/Berchtesgaden and 2) The Rhine Valley. I do not see the value in making a detour into the Alsace but instead would suggest routing yourself through all the wonderful places in between MUC and FRA. I would favor the routing via Nuremberg to FRA, which you see on this map:

https://i.stack.imgur.com/MdA3U.png

And because Nuremberg is both a wonderful place to visit AND an ideal base town for train outings, I suggest that you settle in there for a few days:

https://www.reise.de/wp-content/uploads/sites/16/nuernberg-altstadt.jpeg

Map showing Nuremberg, railways, and nearby destinations:

https://images.gutefrage.net/media/fragen-antworten/bilder/459443150/0_full.jpg?v=1655930239000

4 "Beautiful old places" you can visit by train from Nuremberg...

Bamberg (UNESCO World Heritage status) - https://i.pinimg.com/originals/6f/c1/16/6fc1167bf6d58d92ec06637eea97fdbe.jpg

Iphofen (art/wine town) - scroll through 2 pages of photos: https://www.stadtbild-deutschland.org/forum/index.php?thread/2985-iphofen-galerie/

Bad Windsheim - https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g198421-d284746-Reviews-Frankonian_Open_Air_Museum-Bad_Windsheim_Middle_Franconia_Franconia_Bavaria.html

Rothenburg (beautiful but a bit of a tourist trap...)

Rhine Valley - wonderful for castles, hiking, wine, river cruises, old-world towns. 3 nights here would be best, or 2 nights plus one final night in Mainz or at FRA airport. Boppard makes for a good stay - many good dining and lodging choices with river views, plus free local train trips to other towns (St. Goar, Braubach and Marksburg Castle, Cochem.) Map of Rhine Valley with transport and hiking information:

http://www.loreley-info.com/eng/rhein-rhine/walking-hiking.php

Posted by
19092 posts

My suggestion for traveling from Munich to the Rhein Gorge would be:

Day 1: Munich to Lindau (2½ hrs). RE96 makes the trip directly from Munich Hbf to the island station at Lindau. The island city of Lindau is one of my favorite places in Germany with it's picturesque harbor and it's view of the Swiss mountains. Leave Munich early and plan to spend some time in Lindau.

Day 2: Lindau to Gengenbach (about 4 hours). Take a regional train along the north coast of Bodensee to Singen. Possible stop in Friedrichshafen at the Zeppelin museum. From Singen, take another regional train through the southern Black Forest, along the Schwarzwaldbahn from Triberg to Hausach, then to Gengenbach.

Day 3: Gengenbach to Bingen (3¾ hr). Take a local train from Gengenbach to Offenburg, change to another regional train for a trip via Karlsruhe, through the Palatinate (Speyer, Worms) to Mainz, then down the Rhein to Rüdesheim or Bingen (Stadt), from which you can take a KD ship down the river to Bacharach, St Goar, or St Goarshausen.