Please sign in to post.

Dinner recommendations in Colmar

We will be in Colmar for two nights in August and I am looking for recommendations on where to dine. I have looked through the list on TripAdvisor, but would love some suggestions informed by personal experience.

We like small places, moderately priced, with an emphasis on fresh local cuisine. Outside tables are a plus (unless that comes with smokers at the next table).*. We appreciate most French food, but do not eat foie gras nor escargot, both of which seem to occupy a favored place on many cartes. I have also seen "small birds" and guinea pig (cochon) listed, to some dismay. We do enjoy all kinds of seafood, but Colmar is not on the seaside, so seafood is not exactly "local". Beef and chicken are fine, and we both like salads and vegetables of all kinds. A menu only in French, or French plus German, would be fine.

One issue is that we will be there on Monday and Tuesday nights, and many places are closed one or both nights. L'Arpège was at the top of my list until I saw they are only open for dinner Wednesday.through Saturday. Le Cordon Bleu is open on Monday nights and looks decent; can anyone provide feedback on this place?

  • What is the smoking rule in Alsace restaurants? My husband cannot tolerate nearby smoke.

Thanks for your help!

Posted by
6486 posts

We were in Colmar only one night. We ate at Koifhus Winstub, (https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g187073-d1958997-Reviews-Restaurant_Colmar_au_Koifhus-Colmar_Haut_Rhin_Grand_Est.html) I believe it was a Sunday night. My husband had Backeoffe, an Alsacian meat and vegetable one pot meal. I had pork loin and spaetzle as part of a fixed price meal that included escargot and apple tart. We enjoyed our meal in the large outdoor eating area. I noticed a lot of people eating Tarte Flambe', which was the first time I had seen/heard of the meal. Now I'm quite taken with it and make it myself. I don't enjoy smoke, either, and don't recall it being a problem. You could probably get a table off to the side or in a quarter. They also have a large indoor eating area. I know in Paris and I think in other areas of France, smoking is not allowed inside restaurants but permitted outside.

Posted by
776 posts

that was the restaurant we wanted to eat at but they were full. Looked amazing. Wish we could have tried it.

Posted by
6486 posts

I believe in French (I barely know 30 words), cochon means pig or pork. And I just googled and found out cochon d'Inde is guinea pig. Cochon de lait, is suckling pig.

Posted by
17438 posts

Thanks! I am so relieved it was not guinea pig. I know they eat that in Peru but I was surprised to see it on a French menu.

Is Tarte Flambée really that good? The top-rated restaurant in Colmar (La Soi) serves only that. Wonder if we should give it a try?

Posted by
6486 posts

I love the tarte flambe'. (The German name is flammekuchen) The kind I tried and make is called tarte flambe' gratine, which means that it is topped with gruyere cheese. It is typically a crust with a white cheese like quark or creme fraiche topped with ham/bacon and sauteed onions. It can be quite rich. I'd prefer to split one and have a salad, but my husband typically is not in the mood to do any splitting! Tarte Flambe' is delicious with a reisling or gewurztaminer.

Posted by
17438 posts

Thanks for the description. I actually do not eat wheat so would have to eat just the topping, which makes for a rather rich dish. But my husband would love it. If the place serves dishes other than Tarte Flambée we could both be happy.

Our favorite Alsatian white wine is Pinot Blanc. We had it for our wedding dinner and order it when dining out, if we see it offered.

Posted by
2588 posts

We ate at the Pfeffel which is very near the Unterlinden. Decent food, outdoor tables

Posted by
11294 posts

I can't specifically speak to the rules in Colmar, but everywhere in Europe where smoking is banned at restaurants indoors, it's still permitted at the outdoor tables. (Whether it's legal or not, people smoke at the outdoor tables and they are not stopped). So, if your husband cannot tolerate smoke, you will unfortunately have to sit indoors.

Murphy's Law means that when I sit down outdoors with no smokers nearby, smokers will soon come and sit next to me. If the Law is in full force, they don't come early on, when I can still change tables, but after my food has arrived and I'm in the middle of eating, so I'm stuck with their smoke. So, as one smoke-averse person to another - sit indoors, or you'll be sorry!