Please sign in to post.

BofA debit cards in ATMs

While in France my BofA ATM Debit card didn’t work. Kept getting error messages or if the transaction went all the way to BofA it was reversed. Tried it at several different acquirer banks including BNP Paribus which is supposedly a partner with no luck. Had to use our credit card and incur a cash advance fee. Talked to BofA person with no help. They don’t do travel alerts anymore so I couldn’t have notified them ahead of time of our travels. We should have walked into a BNP branch to see help but didn’t take the time. Have had no problems with previous numerous trips. Anyone use a BofA debit card successfully in an ATM recently in France?

Posted by
1584 posts

I doubt anyone in a BNP branch could have debugged the issue on the spot. While
there are a lot of possible explanations, it seems likely that some sort of setting on
your account is causing the issue. If BNP is a partner, what does this mean? Both
banks need to be part of the same ATM network (e.g., Cirrus, STAR, Bancomat) or
those networks need to talk to each other.

If you saved a receipt from one of the unsuccessful attempts, you might contact BofA
(maybe a bank branch, but more likely an IT Customer Service rep) and see if any of
the information on the receipt allows them to find the transaction and see what went
wrong.

Also, just in case, your cash advance is most likely being treated by the bank as a loan
and on top of the fee, they may be charging you interest. Check this and pay the loan
back asap to stop the additional interest.

Finally, it seems unlikely, but maybe there was some sort of phishing thing going on, so
consider changing your PIN.

Posted by
4 posts

When I talked to a BofA person on the phone she checked and I had nothing on my debit card that would block the transaction. When a transaction is not completed there is no receipt.

Posted by
2396 posts

Did you call the number on back and talk to a customer service rep? We’ve had problems on our last couple of trips with our local Interstate Bank, telling them we would be in Europe, being assured our ATM card would work and still having to spend time calling all over to get the card to work, all with apologies, of course.

Posted by
9686 posts

I have seen similar happen with traveling companions, despite notifying the bank, despite having used the card in Europe before, they try, and no luck.

I have as many as three debit cards that I can use, a Schwab card that always seems to work, and then two credit union cards, but it seems I rarely need to get cash (maybe once a trip), unless I am in Germany. Having a back-up is always a good idea.

My initial; guess for you was maybe fraud detection. Even though you put in travel notices, most banks will still flag a card if it detects unusual use. Their preference is to call you to approve or deny the activity. If you did not have service on your home phone, they may have tried, and failed a confirmation. However, I would think that they would have a record of it.

Posted by
2015 posts

Our not BofA debit card which worked all over France and the Netherlands then wouldn't work in Switzerland. It would ask something about wanting the conversion in Swiss currency or US currency. We kept choosing Swiss currency. No go. We chose US and then it let us. We still aren't sure what happened, but since we were only getting 200 swiss francs, we just went with it.

Sometimes there's just nothing that makes sense about why it declines.

Posted by
1693 posts

BofA charges fees for overseas use anyway. I never use mine when traveling outside of the U.S. even though it is my primary card and account when here. Fortunately, I have other credit cards, and a debit card from TD Bank, that do not charge foreign transaction charge fees.

Posted by
8943 posts

I used mine in Spain earlier this year and the transaction didn’t go through the first time. It was a user error. When the machine asked whether the money should come from savings or checking, I clicked savings when the account is actually checking. On my second try, clicking the correct type account, I got the money. A short call to BoA when I returned and it credited the bank fee back to my account. There’s no getting around the foreign transaction fee, but it was nominal.

Posted by
3332 posts

To comment globally on ATM withdrawals in France, none of these French banks charge local fees when making ATM withdrawals:

  • LCL
  • CCF
  • BNP
  • La Poste

BofA has some of the most costly foreign withdrawal fees of any US bank; 3% plus $5 if using other than BNP. Before making a credit card cash advance, I would at least try each of the above bank ATMs. Some high value customers have these fees waived by BofA. It would seem difficult to explain why your debit card did not work for you and not likely that staff at a local branch could explain it either.

You'll incur no fees if you use one of the above banks as a Swab One customer. Many smaller banks, such as USAA, only pass along the 1% currency conversion fee imposed by the ATM network; Cirrus, All Points, Pulse, Moneypass to name a few.

Posted by
223 posts

No recent use in France, but our BoA debit card worked fine in Ireland and Scotland in May.

shoeflyer, if you use your BoA card at a "partner bank" it means there won't be an ATM transaction fee (though they do charge a 3% foreign exchange fee).

Posted by
2254 posts

If the European bank is a 'correspondent bank' of BofA, there is no transaction fee. I've used it successfully in a few countries, seem to recall Germany & perhaps Italy without incurring a fee. I hope you can sort it out, if you have the time, I would definitely call the number on the card. Good luck!