We will be in York and London in December. Shoukd we bring an umbrella? I have been to England several times and have not, relying on a raincoat. There was only one downpour in Cambridge where I regretted that as my legs got soaked. Otherwise, I have been just fine. But I have been there in May, June, and July not December.
We always take an umbrella when visiting the UK. There have been a number of occasions in Nov-Dec timeframe when an umbrella was handy. Being wet when it’s 70-80 degrees is one thing, but another when it’s 35-45 degrees.
In London, you are more likely to get rain than snow in December. Whether or not you will get a downpour is anyone’s guess.
I always bring an umbrella with me. The compact ones take up very little space. Alternatively, you can pop into just about any Boots and buy one if you need one.
In London or any big city umbrellas are a menace, simply a device for poking people in the eye and they should be illegal. They aren’t going to keep your legs dry. Anywhere else they are totally useless. Wear something with a hood or go to the pub until different weather arrives ( this usually takes 20-25 minutes).
In my experiences in either November or December London travel I’ve only once endured a downpour. Early years would take an umbrella and never use. Thus decades of visits without one. Love my knee length hooded rain coat.
As a person who lives in a rainy place, I want to echo what Trelawney said. Umbrellas are not for getting around in the rain. A waterproof rain jacket with a hood (propped up by a ball cap, as I learned here on the Forum) is your best protection against the rain while walking anywhere. A doorway, shop or pub adds a layer of protection in a city setting. Umbrellas are for amateurs.
We’re just wrapping up a two-week trip to London/Salisbury/Bath/back-to-London, and there’s been some rain, but no downpours. Locals (or fellow tourists?) have had some umbrellas up (often even if the rain has stopped!), and others have hooded jackets.
The rain has been intermittent, and much of it has happened overnight. During daytime, we’ve pretty much lucked out, with it raining mostly while we were inside a museum or restaurant or a train, ending before we needed to walk somewhere. A couple of light sprinkles were no problem with a hooded rain shell. Wind can make things cold, with or without rain. We got some long underwear layers at a Uniqlo store (they are all over London) in December last year, because of the wind chill. We‘d left all ours at home, and brought some this November trip, but haven’t needed it.
Several people have been carrying around compact travel umbrellas, folded up, when rain has been forecast. There’s been no day of solid, continuous rain, and again, no deluges. If you wind up wanting/needing a “brolly,” stores all over sell them, and you can get a cheap one in England that you can toss or give away before you fly home, without having to pack one. Just remember the real adversary is potential wind!
I learned the hard way that relying on a "waterproof" jacket in heavy rain is very uncomfortable.
I have a small, pocket size (6") compact umbrella that stays in the pocket of my jacket. Nothing fancy, nothing expensive.
In light rain, it stays in my pocket. If it gets heavier, out it comes.
Since it stays in my jacket pocket, it doesn't count against any weight restrictions.
I’m a knee-length lightweight hooded puffa coat kind of person and haven’t carried an umbrella in years. I think they’re a pain to carry and get in people’s way. Plus they do my shoulder/back in.
I’m British, by the way, and live in a particularly rainy area.
Incidentally my coats are so lightweight that they can just about fit into a small ROKA backpack when I go indoors, so they’re not even a hassle to carry around.
I've noticed there tends to be a bit of an anti-umbrella bias on this forum. I will respectfully disagree, we use umbrellas all the time when it's raining. We do the same as Frank- if it's light rain we just deal with it and put our hoods up, if heavier we get out the umbrella. I personally would bring (a travel-sized) one. December is perhaps our rainiest month.
I will note that if you are someone who likes to carry a bag (e.g. handbag or backpack) then a waterproof coat will not help keep that dry unless you can fit it underneath. That is another reason I like to use an umbrella.
Whether you need to bring an umbrella probably depends on your opinion of umbrellas.
It’s likely to rain in London in December and it could be light, heavy, intermittent or constant, constant being the least likely.
As a London commuter I would use an umbrella, for example if I was standing at a bus stop with no shelter for a length of time, but more often I would just put my hood up. A wet umbrella is a pain to carry.
What I wouldn’t be without is properly waterproof shoes. Nothing worse than wet feet.
I can't remember when I last used an umbrella. They do keep your top half dry but your legs still get wet.
They are a menace, especially on busy pavements. They are a safety hazard as they can block your view and can also poke other people in the face. They were made popular by city types with bowler hats who used the umbrella as a walking stick
They are useless in wind too. Even sturdy ones can blow unside out. Think how many broken umbrellas you see discarded.
Get yourself a waterproof with a hoid and also a pair of waterproof trousers (not over trousers) . You can get quite stylish ones.
a cold, northern location that’s notorious for rain (or
worse)
I think we need to keep a sense of proportion here:-) London is major world city in a temperate location not the arctic or the jungle!
Despite its reputation, London is drier than many other European cities including Paris and Rome.
What it is, is grey and overcast in the winter. Rain is most likely to be a drizzle and it would be very unlikely to hang around all day. Being a city with lots of places to shelter, it is also very easy to escape the rain.
Wear thin layers that you can easily remove with a good waterproof jacket and waterproof shoes. For me waterproof trousers are totally unnecessary in a town or city but others will disagree.
York will likely be a little colder and a little wetter but not by much.
Travelling in the UK you will soon learn to tell the difference between ‘wet rain’ and ‘not so wet rain’. Also all the different terminology we have for it!
I never use an umbrella. I actually had to buy one recently because my daughter has quite a long walk to school and she wanted one. The only exception might be if I was going out in heavy rain in the evening and I wanted to wear a nice coat rather than a rain jacket.
I agree, waterproof trousers are a bit extreme for London. The time I am usually using an umbrella is walking from my home to the tube and then the tube to wherever my intended destination is. It's for when you need to be outdoors for a short time during heavy rain. The thing is, unless you are committed to a specific outdoor activity, like a long distance walk, you are probably going to be minimising your time outdoors while it's raining anyway.
Either way, it's up to everyone however they choose to stay dry... I mostly want to push back on the idea that no one uses umbrellas here, which is definitely not true.
Since it stays in my jacket pocket, it doesn't count against any weight restrictions.
Frank II, do you board a plane wearing/carrying your coat, with the compact umbrella in your coat? No issues at Security?
Thanks for all the opinions! We do have heavy rain in Florida and I use an umbrella routinely to go between my car and wherever I am going and walking the dog. I agree that I would minimize my time outdoors in England if it was a heavy rain. The only exception would be Kew gardens where we have reservations to see it all lit up.
I am leaning towards buying umbrellas in London if it seems they would be useful.
I did buy a longer raincoat (thigh length) for this trip which would help.
It would be very unlucky to experience anything like a Florida tropical downpour in London at anytime of the year but even less likely in December.
Umbrellas are used. Recall my appreciation of my ability to dodge them as we walked from Zedel’s to the theatre. Plenty of places to buy them.
My raincoat goes to my knees. Shoes water proof.
All about comfort.
I was looking for an umbrella in London during a downpour a couple of Octobers ago and I remember they were ridiculous expensive. Some hotels have umbrellas for their guests, but Premier Inn did not. Maybe ask your hotel if they have umbrellas.
or make an event of it and go to the most fabulous umbrella / walking stick / shooting stick holdover from Victorian days umbrella shop to beat all other umbrella shops... James Smith & Son, on the corner of Shaftsbury Avenue (at Bloomsbury Street) and New Oxford Street, London.
You could spend a day in there and then have to explain to your bank manager. They have sold me many things, but I've avoided the very expensive things... whew!
They have been going non-stop since 1830 - they have been at the same shop in New Oxford Street since 1857. I love it.
https://www.james-smith.co.uk/
Oh, and I don't use an umbrella. We have one from days living in Fort Worth in the 1970s from the Startle Gram, the Fort Worth Star Telegram, and another from Ikea of much more recent vintage, and several pocket ones, but they are all for my wife. I wear a waterproof jacket on wet rain days (a fleece on not wet rain days) and a waxed wide brimmed (with a feather) country gentleman's hat which keeps off all but the very heaviest rain - no umbrella for me.