Please sign in to post.

Settle/Carlisle Railway- Emergency Closure between Appleby and Skipton

A retaining wall has failed on the Settle/Carlisle line between Kirkby Stephen and Garsdale.

As a result trains are suspended until further notice between Appleby and Skipton, with rail replacement buses serving all stations Appleby to Skipton except Dent.

All time restrictions have been lifted on all ticket types on the line, tickets may also be used from Carlisle on TPE trains via Preston, then the Preston to Leeds service (also on Northern Lancaster to Skipton/Leeds services), and to Leeds from Carlisle via Newcastle and York.

Journey times are extended by up to two hours.

Posted by
138 posts

Thank you isn31c for alerting us to this issue!
We have a holiday booked in April in Settle and we’re planning on getting there and around by train. I know it’s a big ask, but do you have any idea on whether this might be a lengthy closure, or can you point me in the direction of information sources where I could keep an eye on the situation?
Thank you very much.

Posted by
11267 posts

The incident only happened at 1pm this afternoon. Network Rail already have engineering teams on site clearing the collapse and assessing repairs needed. So at this stage we simply don't know how bad this is, but the photographs are not good. Whether a temporary quick repair can be put in place remains to be seen.

Northern Rail journey check will be updating on a regular basis- https://www.northernrailway.co.uk/service-updates

Northern Rail have an arrangement with a local company to have 4 buses on standby 24/7 so that is how buses were on site so fast

There is also a local Skipton to Settle (and on to Ingleton, Kirkby Lonsdale and Lancaster- hourly to Settle, two hourly beyond Settle towards Lancaster.

In theory trains could be extended south to Kirkby Stephen and north to Ribblehead (apparently trains can't be turned at Settle) so it's a waiting game.

Posted by
138 posts

Thank you very much isn31c.
I will keep an eye on the website in your link and if need be, make a decision in early April while our accommodation is still able to be cancelled. We are planning on using the local trains to explore for a week.
Will keep fingers crossed.

Posted by
505 posts

We have train reservations from Skipton to Carlisle on April 30 so I will be checking in on the Northern Rail updates as well.

Posted by
11267 posts

Overnight Network Rail have "done a Shap"- that is to say worked like trojans to clear the line of debris/make the area safe and re-opened the line to traffic. There is a Temporary Speed Restriction through the site, but there is recovery time built into the schedule at various locations, so the effect should be minimal.

The reference to Shap is to the Avanti derailment in December- the expectation was that the line would be closed for weeks, but was re-opened in around 20 hours with a temporary fix, after scores of engineers worked in foul weather, at a remote location mainly overnight.

Like Shap planned engineering/line closure(s) will be needed in due course to make a permanent repair but for now the line is open.

It's a bit of a shame for me- I have an upcoming trip to make from West Cumbria to Selby Abbey (near York), on a Northern Rail free ticket. It is awaiting better weather because I need to make a stop off at Steeton for a technical condition assessment on their war memorial. If the line had remained closed that was going to be done today or tomorrow regardless of weather, because the epic bus ride from Appleby to Skipton is one of the few RRB's in Northern England I haven't managed to do over the years, but want to. Scenically it has to be one of the great bus journeys (if a long one)- one you would never ever do by car as no-one (even me) would choose to drive station to station through the Dales, no matter how scenic.

A few years ago we had a 13 month closure between Carlisle and Appleby after a landslide. For the same reason I enjoyed the frequent RRB all stations rides through the Eden Valley- again because of the scenery, but it is a route no one would ever drive. I took the all stations RRB instead of the express, because who wants to see the boring A66/M6. I can get that anytime.