Hadrian's Wall

Rabbies? Always highly recommended on these forums. This one from Edinburgh covers Hadrian’s Wall and the Borders: https://www.rabbies.com/en/england-tours/from-edinburgh/day-tours/hadrians-wall-roman-britain-the-scottish-borders-day-tour

I don’t know of this company but they offer bespoke tours: https://www.visitscotland.com/info/tours/solway-tours-hadrians-wall-and-roman-britain-day-tour-cf9958fd

A few years ago, we hiked the length of the Wall, coast to coast, so we didn’t hire a specific tour company. We did take guided tours offered at particular sites, like Chester’s Fort and at Vindolanda. Those weren’t prearranged, and we just signed up when we reached the place.

I wonder, are you looking for a tour where you’d be traveling in your car? Maybe with a guide riding along?

+1 to post #1.

March 2022 I did the Hadrian’s Wall and Borders tour with Rabbie’s from Edinburgh. Excellent tour. Nice tour of Roman sites plus got in some 16th century history too. I especially liked the small group tour size.

Normally I would always recommend a private tour with Peter Carney, but I'm not sure if he will pick up out those two cities.
Here is the link to his website.
https://www.hadrianswall-walk.com/

I've never come across a day tour from York to Hadrian's Wall - there are so many closer placces to visit...

I think your only option would be Rabbies from Edinburgh...

Surely you could take an early train from either York or Edinburgh to Newcastle for a Peter Carney tour?

take an early train from either York or Edinburgh to Newcastle for a Peter Carney tour?

Check out the prices for this as a Newcastle pick up adds £100 to the cost of the tour....

RE-Peter Carney- So from Edinburgh take the 0652 train from Edinburgh to Carlisle - arrives 0805, then the 0820 to Haltwhistle or Hexham (in to HW at 0850, Hexham about 0910). Carlisle to Hexham is £2.40 advance single each on the train- beats paying him £125 to meet you at Carlisle.
Likewise from York- early train to Newcastle, then train every half hour to Hexham- £2.30 advance single for the 30 to 40 minute journey- far less than his £100 pick up fee.

The 0635 from York gets you to Hexham at 0837.

Fare from York to Hexham booked ahead is between £19 and £25 each way, Edinburgh to Hexham is between £12 and £15 advance singles (the lower fare being on the 0612 which gets you to HW and Hexham 20 minutes earlier).

Very easy.