Please sign in to post.

500th Anniversary of the German Peasants Revolt

In the winter of 1524-25 serfs in many places of what is now Germany, shading into France and Switzerland, got annoyed enough about being treated as serfs to take direct action.

By March, they were taking over/reclaiming castles and holdings of the oligarchs of their day, largely nonviolently, and they were often citing Martin Luther's objections to the Church's behavioral expectations as a basis for resistance.

Luther himself didn't agree, and took the side of the billionaires-I-mean-aristocrats.

"In his treatise “Admonition to Peace,” Luther complained that the peasants had made “Christian liberty an utterly carnal thing,” which “would make all men equal … and that is impossible.”
Responding to the revolt, Luther produced a tract entitled “Against the Murdering and Robbing Hordes of Peasants.” “Let everyone who can,” he infamously wrote, “smite, slay, and stab” the rebellious peasants. The rulers did just that."

When the nobility organized their own armies, the peasants didn’t stand a chance. On the battlefield, the nobles’ cavalry and superior artillery brutally cut down the rebels. Many who escaped the battlefield were hunted down and executed.

https://theconversation.com/500-years-ago-german-peasants-revolted-but-their-faith-that-the-protestant-reformation-stood-for-freedom-was-dashed-by-martin-luther-and-the-nobility-246378

Luther’s rejection of the peasants had important long-term consequences. His decision to side with the princes transformed the Reformation from a grassroots movement into an act of state. Everywhere the Protestant reformers went, they sought to work with the authorities. The close cooperation of Christian leaders and secular authorities would last for centuries.

Posted by
2933 posts

Before anyone complains to our webmaster that this isn't sufficiently travel-related,
let me ask for everyone's advice on the best towns and castles to visit to learn more
about this part of German/Protestant history, and what your favorite memories of visiting have been.

Have there been other countries in Europe where the church officials and the state authorities were aligned together in opposition to the popular classes? (Yes, I am being funny.)

Posted by
15300 posts

Augsburg....Peace of Augsburg, the princes decide the religion for their subjects.

Nobles , the church and the state aligned to put down a popular uprising....Pugachev's Rebellion in 1773

Posted by
3593 posts

A lot of ideology glasses were already put onto this historical chapter or German Peasants' War, e. g. German revolution by Wilhelm Zimmermann, Marxist version by Engels based on Zimmermann, also some Nazi interpretations (e. g. glorfication of Florian Geyer) and so on. Question is which version Mr. Bruening was following because not all were assuming that Luther was an origin and that this movement was meant against the church. Also Müntzer was acting very publicly before Luther, e. g. reading original bible text in German language to a few hundred people. But afaik it is still unclear 1) if the religious revolution persons had original influence and 2) which one to also name Zwingli. So I put a big question mark on Bruenings "... but they also drew inspiration from the message of freedom, or “Fryheit” in German, being preached by theologian Martin Luther,...".

I also do not believe "Luther’s rejection of the peasants’ cause, however, would help lead to their crushing defeat." (no source mentioned). From what I heard and read Luther's influence was by far not big enough for this - and he was in deep dispute with other guys such as Zwingli.

Sure things happened in parallel at similar regions but they were coming from different backgrounds and reasons also with different targets. Finally I miss the compelling evidence to support Bruening's title in this form.

advice on the best towns and castles

If you read the history the places are somehow obviously (link to map), e. g.

  • Stühlingen castle (one place of origin)
  • Wurzach
  • Memmingen (12 articles)
  • Böblingen (museum, visit 500 yr. exhibition)
  • Marienberg Castle (Würzburg)
  • Königshofen
  • Mühlhausen
  • Bad Frankenhausen (panorama, Marxist ideology)
  • and so on.

Do not miss visiting exhibition in Stuttgart until October 2025.

Have there been other countries in Europe where the church officials and the state authorities were aligned together in opposition to the popular classes? (Yes, I am being funny.)

Yes, a few. Examples I know of - and for sure there are dozens of other peasant revolts in the history of this huge continent.

  • Frisian Freedom (very remarkable because no revolution but awarding from sovereign)
  • Peasants' Revolt 1381 (England)
  • Engelbrekt rebellion (Sweden)
  • one in Norway but I miss the name and year

So, in total the Bauernkrieg was an important step in history which caused (depending on region) some smaller or larger changes.

Posted by
2933 posts

Thank you Sam for the pointer to the panorama -- there are so few of those remaining! They were very popular in the USA for a few decades before photography became affordable.

MarkK -- when I said I was being funny that was because I was being funny. All of the relevant historical episodes that come to my mind involve the (higher) clergy siding with the rulers against the populace, it's just that my mind is apt to lean in the direction of the civilized, Romance-language-based, parts of Europe, while yours, it is apparent, focuses on the other parts.

Isn't it so true that we put ourselves (or our side/team) in the center of the story and therefore see it from that vantage? The story of Europe for me is a story of the spread of culture from the north side of the Mediterranean through the meaner/baser parts of the Continent above. While yours, I imagine, is more a story of resistance and then reluctant acceptance of invading notions of morality and taste that suppressed the proud hairy heads of the indigenous inhabitants when they spread up from the south.

Posted by
21839 posts

There you go, being funny again!

I was interested in the history of the panorama. As pointed out by MarkK, it was conceived as Marxist propaganda by the GDR, taking 10 years to execute by a team of artists and craftsmen under the direction of the master, and 2 months after it opened, the Berlin Wall fell. The GDR was no more one year later.

I just saw the Gettysburg Panorama this past summer. It is over 100 years old and has been completely restored.

Posted by
2933 posts

I saw the Gettysburg panorama in the '70s and my main takeaway from the deluxe tour of the battle site was that it was a lot longer than I had anticipated. Should have brought snacks.