Please sign in to post.

Varying enforcement of liquids rule in US vs. Europe

If you have traveled at least once since 2006, you would know that hand luggage liquids are restricted to 3.4 oz (100 mL) per container, and need to be placed in a clear, 1 quart plastic bag. Each passenger can only carry one bag with their hand luggage (cabin bag).

However, a trend that I have noticed in my travels is that the enforcement of this differs wildly in various parts of the world. In the US, for example, liquid containers cannot exceed 100 mL or 3.4 oz, but the plastic bag/1 bag per passenger parts of the 3-1-1 rule have almost never been enforced in the last 10-15 years or so.

But in Europe, it's a different picture. The usual suspects for strict enforcement are in Britain, namely London Heathrow. In mainland Europe, it depends on the country/airport. Some do (Frankfurt and Paris, I'm looking at you), some don't (Amsterdam, Rome, Zurich, Dublin, Helsinki, etc.).

Of course, it is true that many countries, including the UK and US, have implemented new CT scanners that allow passengers to keep their liquids and electronics in their bags for screening. But is it a case that some countries simply don't see a supposed science experiment involving liquid explosives going wrong above 30,000 feet as much of a threat, whereas others do? Could it be possible that European countries are stricter due to them being more vulnerable to bad actors targeting air travel there? After all, the foiled terror plot that happened in 2006 which led to the liquids rule occurred in the UK, hence explaining their over-cautiousness.

I'd love to know your thoughts.

Posted by
16967 posts

Liquids rules can vary from airport to airport, from terminal to terminal, and even from lane to lane.

I was at Heathrow a couple of years ago when one line was being split into two different xray machines. The line to the left had to take their liquids bag out of their bags. The line to the right didn't.

Some airports in the EU didn't make anyone take liquids or electronics out of their bags because they had the advanced machinery. But then the EU decided that until all airports are up to speed, everyone had to take their liquids out.

In the US, I have PreCheck so I never have to take my liquids out. But I go through enough airports around the world that I'm always ready to take the 3-1-1 bag out unless told otherwise.

In the US, many airports are getting advanced scanners so it's not necessary to take the 3-1-1 bag out. But it's going to vary from airport to airport.

The EU is not stricter than the US. In fact, if an airport has flights to the US, and they don't have a separate security area for US bound flights, then they must follow TSA guidelines.

Regarding non-enforcement on the one bag rule. I've seen it, or heard TSA agents saying, "one bag only." Perhaps not where you were.

Posted by
21853 posts

Varying enforcement of liquids rule in US vs. Europe I'd love to know
your thoughts.

Follow the rules, then you dont have to worry about it and potentially the line moves faster and those behind you dont have to wait while yoiu explain to the inspector that ......

Posted by
577 posts

Follow the rules, then you dont have to worry about it

I don't see where the original poster is asking how to circumvent the rules. They're asking if we've observed differences.

I have, and I have wondered about them. I have TSA precheck which means I never have to take my toiletries bag out in the US. I always have a small tube of hand lotion and a lip balm in a pocket in my shoulder bag and often I forget to transfer those to my toiletries bag before I travel. I've never been flagged for that ever in the US. However I always remember to transfer them when I'm coming home because I always feel like screening overseas is more strict.

One requirement that varies widely in the US is whether or not you have to take food out your bag when going through security. The TSA screeners in the non-TSA lines are particularly militant about that, but I don't often hear it in other US airports.

Yesterday I went through security screening in Berlin. There was a young American couple in front of me. The man had his toiletries in a big canvas toiletries bag and acted suprised when the screener handed him a plastic bag and said to put all his toiletries in it. When I gathered my things to leave the screening area, another screener was going through the woman's carry on and pulling full-sized toiletries out of it. How did they manage to leave the country without knowing about the "311 rule"?? Or did they think it didn't apply outside the US?

Posted by
4800 posts

In Athens, Greece, they took the correct travel sized bottle of contact lens solution in my 3-1-1 bag. A few years later when leaving that airport, they took everything out of my carryon. I'd be especially careful at that airport.

Posted by
21853 posts

I have noticed in my travels is that the enforcement of this differs
wildly
in various parts of the world

Sorry jaydeshpande55 out of random curiosity its an interesting observation and might give some indication of how long security will take. In dealing with the pratical application though, if you conform to the rules without consideration of how strictly the enforcement of those rules is applied, the question isnt one to worry about.

And we all screw up. Last year I carried a knife through 4 security check points (was on my keychain and i forgot). Then there is the never knowing if I have to take off my belt. Even with a plastic buckle some make me, others not. If I were better, I would just take it off and not worry about it.