I stopped by REI's garage sale today, and picked up a great pair of Keens for $58 today! I'm headed to Italy this summer and think these will be a great casual, comfortable and supportive shoe for my trip. I tried on so many last year, and these were much better than anything I wore last time.
The "black" (really more grey) and red ones are marked down already, with an extra 30% off for members.
https://www.rei.com/product/872966/keen-reisen-lace-shoes-womens